September 13, 2010

Meet Staff Sergeant Salvatore Giunta, Medal Of Honor Recipient
— DrewM

An American hero gives his first TV interview.

27CDB6E-AE6D-11cf-96B8-444553540000" codebase="http://download.macromedia.com/pub/shockwave/cabs/flash/swflash.cab#version=9,0,124,0" width="344" height="278" id="ABCESNWID">

This was a tease for the interview that aired this evening, I'll keep an eye for the full story.

It's about time the military did this. I refuse to believe that after 9 years of war in Afghanistan and 7+ in Iraq, only 7 men (including Giunta) have done something to merit the Medal of Honor. I have no idea why the military has taken this approach to the Medal of Honor but it does the whole nation a disservice. It's about more than the men and women who might be considered for the Medal, they do not act out of a desire for medals or recognition but those that will come after them need inspirational figures. Our country needs these heroes, especially those that survive.

Thank God for men like SSG Salvatore Giunta.


(I corrected the abbreviation for Staff Sergeant. Thanks to Ed for the heads up)

Posted by: DrewM at 03:31 PM | Comments (93)
Post contains 174 words, total size 3 kb.

1 The relative rarity of Medal of Honors does make it a more important medal to receive. During the US Civil War they gave out way to many and ended up rescinding a lot of them. I read a article that listed the reason a bunch of the medals were given in the past and the accounts were of a truly heroic nature.

Posted by: Bill at September 13, 2010 03:35 PM (LZSir)

2

The reporter chick said "He's one of 7 medal of Honor winners."  It's a recipient!  Yeesh.

Anyways, love that Staff Sargeant and all those who are sacrificing so much by serving over there.  Wow.

Posted by: runningrn at September 13, 2010 03:36 PM (8GYOu)

3

Thank God for men like SSgt Salvatore Giunta.

 

Thank God, indeed. 

Posted by: Soona at September 13, 2010 03:44 PM (XWRkx)

4 Thank God SSGT Giunta was able to save the other soldier from that sorry band of men. Well deserved.

Posted by: delmar at September 13, 2010 03:45 PM (bPYiy)

5 I disagree.  The Navy... I'll speak for them... gives out NAMs and COMs like they're candy.  Seriously.  It's as if the cooks and yeomen are swinging at a big NAM pinata and every one of them rushes in to pick up what falls.  A cook bakes a cake that the Commodores wife enjoys.  NAM.  A YN3 escorts a group of VIP's around the boat on his duty day.  NAM.  And then some non-rate seaman gets upset when he only gets an Admirals letter for qualifying dolphins three months late.    The CMOH is what it is.  It's the last and only award left that has any dignity.  I'm not discrediting the service of those who've been nominated and denied.  A Navy Cross isn't too shabby either.  Leave the CMOH alone.  Let it be for the truly extraordinary.

Posted by: 2549 at September 13, 2010 03:45 PM (kr1RX)

6 Don't mistake my tirade as judgment on the SSGT.  I'm not doubting the fact that he is a badass.  He's getting this honor.  I'm elated.  I just don't want to see the politics of awarding the CMOH sully the dignity of it in any way.

Posted by: 2549 at September 13, 2010 03:48 PM (kr1RX)

7 God bless him and all our other heroes, medals or not.

Posted by: Guy Fawkes at September 13, 2010 03:48 PM (L8kaT)

8 May the Lord bless and keep valiant men such as this. 

Posted by: Kratos (Ghost of Sparta) at September 13, 2010 03:50 PM (9hSKh)

9

Hooraahhh SSGT.

I hate that fucking communist Martha Raddich chick though. She is a absolute leftist.

Posted by: robtr at September 13, 2010 03:50 PM (fwSHf)

10 I fully honor this man's heroism, in all ways, and fully accept he deserves the medal. Would I be too much of a cynic to wonder, though, if a Staff Sergeant John Smith would have been so honored, for the same act of heroism?

Posted by: CoolCzech at September 13, 2010 03:50 PM (tJjm/)

11 May the Lord bless and keep valiant men such as this. 

Posted by: Kratos (Ghost of Sparta) at September 13, 2010 07:50 PM (9hSKh)

Kratos, I subbed for you on the previous thread. They were talking about strippers and such and I knew you wouldn't approve.

Posted by: robtr at September 13, 2010 03:51 PM (fwSHf)

12 One of the books I liberated from my grandparents' house this weekend ahead of the auction crew was a child's book (aimed at 10-12 year-old boys) from the 1950s that presented stories of WWII Medal of Honor recipients--where they grew up, and what they did to be awarded the medal. It fascinated me, partly for the stories, and partly because if someone published such a book today, no school library would deign to stock it, lest some child read it and be inspired by actual heroes instead of, say, AlGore.

Thank God for men like SSgt Salvatore Giunta.

Yup yup.

Posted by: HeatherRadish at September 13, 2010 03:54 PM (Vz9lf)

13 I hate to be the first one to say this but this brave warrior has received a metal that he doesn't deserve.

A Silver Star with Clusters - Yes. But not the MOH.

I've been there and done that and seen men do much more than this and only receive ----NOTHING--- or perhaps a Bronze Star.

The MOH is for men or women that do things that they know that they will not survive, that do superhuman things, that go way, way far into terror and death and seldom if ever survive.

Read of the acts of past MOH recipients and tell me that you don't agree.

Papa Ray

Posted by: Papa Ray at September 13, 2010 03:54 PM (JpVJn)

14 Well... Papa Ray... a lot of the old old MOH recipients, circa the civil war, were awarded for acts that wouldn't meet todays standards.  They wouldn't meet WWII or WWI standards, either.  The MOH has evolved over time.  I just would rather not see it go the other direction.

Posted by: 2549 at September 13, 2010 03:57 PM (kr1RX)

15 #11  Kratos, I subbed for you on the previous thread. They were talking about strippers and such and I knew you wouldn't approve.

lol, thanks robtr.  I appreciate the effort, but it wasn't necessary.  In all honesty, I "doth protesth too much" about that sort of thing.  What business is it of mine unless it's interfering with me?

And strip clubs would just happen to stop the GZ mosque construction entirely, hell, I'm all for 'em. 

/But learn to spell "decadence" correctly next time, ok? 

Posted by: Kratos (Ghost of Sparta) at September 13, 2010 04:03 PM (9hSKh)

16 typical libtard interviewer - notice how she couldn't resist inserting her anti-patriotic point of view:  immediately after the heroic SGT mentioned men from all across America were fighting heroically FOR America.....she says, "...so you were fighting for the men beside you...."  A common theme of libtards who want to undermine patriotic deeds and thoughts is that soldiers fight FOR THEIR BUDDIES, NOT America.  Its a gross oversimplification, and libtards play it all the time.  In the here and now, as bullets are flying, sure, soldiers don't give a lot of thought to the Founding Fathers and the abstract concepts of national pride, heritage, and a sense of patriotic obligation....that led them to join the service in the first place.  they naturally are concerned about their foxhole-mates.  But to make a sweeping statement:  "you were fighting for friendship and NOT the nation..." is a gross distortion.  you see it all the time, as liberals seek to downplay patriotism.

Posted by: youbetcha at September 13, 2010 04:05 PM (+Hes1)

17

DrewM:  Thank God for men like SSgt Salvatore Giunta.

DrewM, it isn't SSGT.  It is SSG.  Marines might call it SSGT, but not the Army.

If he is an E-5, his rank is called Sergeant.  SGT.

If he is an E-6, his rank is called Staff Sergeant.  SSG.

If he is an E-7, his rank is called Sergeant First Class.  SFC.

All enlisted ranks are abrieviated to three letters only.

 

 

Posted by: Ed at September 13, 2010 04:12 PM (Zsqn4)

18 youbetcha - great point but notice also how Stephi also couldn't resist saying how excited he was to talk to the President. Undoubtedly true but always looking for a way to say to America "see Obama loves the troops and they love him."

Posted by: bobbymike at September 13, 2010 04:15 PM (WWQLs)

19 @5 by Posted by: 2549 at September 13, 2010 07:45 PM (kr1RX) The Army passes out Army Achievment Medals and Commendation Medals like candy as well. Big deal. Everyone in the service knows a Bronze Star without a "V" device is just a nice "I was there" ribbon. But having read any number of citations for awards in this war and others, it is quite clear that the services have been loathe to award a MoH to a living recipient. The public doesn't pay attention to a DSC/NC/AFC recipient. But they do pay attention to an MoH recipient. My personal take on this? SSG Giunta's award is quite well deserved. But you'll notice that his actions were well publicized in both Junger's book "War" and in the movie "Restrepo" and I'm convinced that if that weren't the case, he would have been downgraded. It's a cryin' shame that awards need PR to just be awarded.

Posted by: XBradTC at September 13, 2010 04:19 PM (X0Ona)

20 WTF is a NAM and a COM? I was in the Navy for 7 years and never heard that acronym for a medal.

And there is no such thing as a CMOH, Congress is nowhere in the title.

Posted by: Vic at September 13, 2010 04:21 PM (/jbAw)

21 A thought:  President Obama must nominate more women to White House offices. Heaven forfend that he would allow experience or expertise to get in the way of such important considerations!

Posted by: Truman North at September 13, 2010 04:22 PM (HLGCA)

22 NAM= Navy Achievement Medal COM= Navy Commendation Medal.

Posted by: XBradTC at September 13, 2010 04:22 PM (X0Ona)

23 President Nero with another packed social calendar this week...

Posted by: Truman North at September 13, 2010 04:23 PM (HLGCA)

24 Ed at september: The Airforce uses the 4 letter designations.SSGT TSGT MSGT SMSGT CMSGT.They are in order,E-5 E-6 E-7 E-8 and E-9.Just thought I'd clear that up.I am still a member.

Posted by: ziptie at September 13, 2010 04:23 PM (0135J)

25 bobbymike - also a good point; not too hard to understand why this short soundbite made it as the teaser.  one point Staphylococcus would never understand, is that maybe the heroic SSGT was subdued (as opposed to the phone call) when recounting the combat is because some of his friends and colleagues died in the gut-wrenching, terrifying action.  to Staphy, it all about the thrill of speaking to the One, rather than reliving the emotions of combat. 

Posted by: youbetcha at September 13, 2010 04:24 PM (+Hes1)

26 NAM= Navy Achievement Medal

COM= Navy Commendation Medal.

Posted by: XBradTC at September 13, 2010 08:22 PM (X0Ona)

Thanks, I didn't here of the acronym because I never heard of the medal. They must not have been giving those out in the early to late 70s.

Posted by: Vic at September 13, 2010 04:24 PM (/jbAw)

27 God bless SSG Salvatore Giunta.

Posted by: Miss'80sBaby at September 13, 2010 04:25 PM (Yq+qN)

28

the fountainhead is on TCM at 845.

 

also does ace know there is an "Ace plays the invisible accordian" picture of him on the web?

Posted by: Ben at September 13, 2010 04:25 PM (DKV43)

29 God Bless SSGT Guinta and all of our men and women in all of the uniformed services.

I had a chance run in with MOH recipient Roy Benavidez  http://tinyurl.com/2vw493t   back in the early 90's and let me tell ya, he had a look that would make a believer out of ya in a hurry.

Posted by: GrumpyUnk at September 13, 2010 04:26 PM (1TTCZ)

30

http://tinyurl.com/349a6lp

Did John pull a Boner?

Posted by: Truman North at September 13, 2010 04:26 PM (HLGCA)

31 Vic, IIRC, the Achievement Medals (each service has their own) came out around 1981.

Posted by: XBradTC at September 13, 2010 04:26 PM (X0Ona)

32 GrumpyUnk, MSG Benavidez' cousin earned the DSC in the same fight that he earned the MoH. I was fortunate to call him my friend for several years.

Posted by: XBradTC at September 13, 2010 04:28 PM (X0Ona)

33

I was hoping this thing would look cooler.  My hopes were dashed.

Militarized skateboard

From the comments:

Nothing paints shoot me first like a god damn scooter. Hell, let's give it a pink paint job and streamers and call it a day. I can just see Opfor passing the sniper around for laughs as they look at the scooter ninny brigade coming into town

Related question:  Why are both of the premiere skateboard-riding superheroes (Rocket Racer and Night Thrasher) both black?

 

Posted by: Truman North at September 13, 2010 04:31 PM (HLGCA)

34

also, the O'Donnell v. Castle fight just got more interesting.

Krauthammer called Demint and Palin's endorsement of O'Donnell destructive and irresponsible.

 

Posted by: Ben at September 13, 2010 04:31 PM (DKV43)

35 26Ed at september: The Airforce uses the 4 letter designations.SSGT TSGT MSGT SMSGT CMSGT.They are in order,E-5 E-6 E-7 E-8 and E-9.Just thought I'd clear that up.I am still a member.

Posted by: ziptie at September 13, 2010 08:23 PM (0135J)

 

Heh.  Err, yes, you are of course correct.  And believe it or not, I knew that at the time of my original post.  What I should have written is:

"All ARMY enlisted ranks are abrieviated to three letters only." 

Poor proof reading on my part.

 

 

 

 

Posted by: Ed at September 13, 2010 04:31 PM (Zsqn4)

36 Posted by: XBradTC at September 13, 2010 08:28 PM (X0Ona)
---------------------------------------------
I'm glad for you that you got to know a guy like that. I was just a E5 who never did shit and just being able to see him, come to attention and snap off my best salute made me feel like a better soldier.

Posted by: GrumpyUnk at September 13, 2010 04:31 PM (1TTCZ)

37 Vic, IIRC, the Achievement Medals (each service has their own) came out around 1981.

Posted by: XBradTC at September 13, 2010 08:26 PM (X0Ona)

OK, I had just finished checking. Wiki says it came out for the Navy in 1961 so it was still relatively new when I was in between 1970 and 77.

I never knew a single person who had received it. We got all kinds of other shit for Vietnam and long "periods in the combat zone at sea" but never heard anything about the NAM (other than slang for Vietnam) 

Probably since it was still new the brass had not figured out what the real criteria was for issuing it.

Posted by: Vic at September 13, 2010 04:32 PM (/jbAw)

38

All enlisted ranks are abrieviated to three letters only.

Same with the Executive Branch; for example, the CINC is a POS.

Posted by: USS Diversity at September 13, 2010 04:32 PM (u3Zi5)

39

40 LOL

(O/T I just took my daily sojourn to HA. My visits are now down to less than a minute. I can actually read the WashPo for longer.)

Posted by: dagny at September 13, 2010 04:34 PM (VneYc)

40

Hey, thanks for the correction DrewM.

And you don't have to mention my name or your correction of the original post.

It was just an insignificant editing mistake.  No need for publicly correcting yourself.

In fact, I really don't feel worthy of being mentioned in his post.

The post is about him.  Not me.

Posted by: Ed at September 13, 2010 04:35 PM (Zsqn4)

41 Ed at september: Sorry,wasn't trying to be a smartass.I'm not familiar with the Army ranks at all. Poor reading the obvious on my part.

Posted by: ziptie at September 13, 2010 04:39 PM (0135J)

42 2549, Roger that.  I got a NAM and COM just for showing up.  Monster badges are a different story.  The best part is I have never heard a CMOH awardee say they deserved it.  One who did not get it was a Marine Lt. who on the drive to Bagdad, ran into stiff resistance from fixed positions.  Ordered his driver to charge the line with his gunner on top of the hummer blazing away.  Ran the hummer into the ditch, jumped out and ran after the enemy down the ditch.  Emptied his M16 and all available ammo, picked up a fucking AK and continued pursuit of the enemy.  I mean, big brass balls.  They gave him the Navy Cross, but damn.  Glad these guys are on our side.  Semper fi.

Posted by: Hammer at September 13, 2010 04:40 PM (hVGDL)

43

ptie at September 13, 2010 08:39 PM (0135J)

No worries, it's all good.

Posted by: Ed at September 13, 2010 04:40 PM (Zsqn4)

44

Evening folks. 

Nothing to add on on this great story.  I understand not wanting to devalue medals, but it seems the military has been awfully stingy the last 10 years. 

Glad we have a guy who lived to tell about his bravery.

Posted by: Delta Smelt at September 13, 2010 04:41 PM (A0VTZ)

45

Err...Sorry about cutting off your nic there in #45.

It's ziptie.

Jeeze.  I make one good correction about abreviations, and then promptly proceed to step all over my dick on several subsequent occasions.

Posted by: Ed at September 13, 2010 04:42 PM (Zsqn4)

46 I have no idea why the military has taken this approach to the Medal of Honor but it does the whole nation a disservice.

WTF you know why the military takes this approach, PC!  Don't honor people in a war that democrats don't support.

Posted by: Kemp at September 13, 2010 04:44 PM (AQxTm)

47 In our world of nutty preachers, stubborn imans and a certifiable political class, it's nice to have a true blue American hero to honor.  Kind of reminds me of the good old days when our president and citizens were proud to be Americans.  Thank God we have people like SSG Giunta on our side. 

Posted by: Mayday at September 13, 2010 04:44 PM (TRgli)

48 He's much more comfortable with presenting medals for running away strategically, and so forth.

Posted by: Wodeshed at September 13, 2010 08:41 PM (MFbfZ)

Yeah and doesn't he now have to salute him?

He might be eating his waffle when it comes time to salute.  Or hitting out of a sand trap.

Posted by: Delta Smelt at September 13, 2010 04:45 PM (A0VTZ)

49
Thanks, I didn't here of the acronym because I never heard of the medal. They must not have been giving those out in the early to late 70s.

Posted by: Vic at September 13, 2010 08:24 PM (/jbAw)

That was long after you left the Navy. Was it fun launching biplanes from the Langley?

Posted by: Ed Anger at September 13, 2010 04:45 PM (7+pP9)

50 God bless SSG Giunta.

I hope he isn't a Ravens fan... 'cause they keep spiking themselves vs the Jets. 

Posted by: Y-not at September 13, 2010 04:45 PM (osFsP)

51 Posted by: Wodeshed Medals reek of victory.

Posted by: Lincolntf at September 13, 2010 04:47 PM (EHI/u)

52

Thank God for brave men like SSG. Giunta. Also, those 2 guys from Blackhawk Down.

One time in the Med a bunch of us decided we'd earned this ribbon just for being off Lebanon; we called it the punkin ribbon because it was orange and black. For some reason the ship's store had it so we had the whole division just wearing this madeup award to all these ceremonies. The Department head went apeshit; a good time was had by all.

Posted by: USS Diversity at September 13, 2010 04:47 PM (u3Zi5)

53 Hooah

Posted by: Pat at September 13, 2010 04:49 PM (SHHSw)

54 Ed at September: I got it. I step all over mine here all the time.

Posted by: ziptie at September 13, 2010 04:53 PM (0135J)

55 I think medals come and go in what it takes to receive them. 

Acts of courage were so common in WW2 and WWI that the award was extraordinary.  Like Papa said, the standard is not as strong as it was then.  The question becomes exactly what is "above and beyond"? 

Today, I think sometimes showing up on time might qualify.

That is not to take away from the duty and guts these Americans show.

I personally know a Distinguished Flying Cross recipient, the second highest award in the AF.  He won't tell what he did to get it, so I am guessing he's the guy that bombed the Chinese Embassy in Bosnia.

Pretty cool, but not like WW2 bombers flying into flack and getting back half shot up.

Posted by: Kemp at September 13, 2010 04:56 PM (AQxTm)

56 re: paucity of medal of honor winners
maybe the people who can award the MofH are the kinda folks not in any position to receive it - that's is high ranking officer in non-combatant positions.  so, if that can't get a MofH, then not one can.  don't know, but maybe.

Posted by: bob at September 13, 2010 04:57 PM (qPTun)

57 #41 Dagny, I hear that. The comments are the most frightening thing- like when they posted Mark Kirk's video in which he promises to stop the Democrats in the lame duck and his "moderate" views take a backseat to stopping a dangerous Congress, and they treat him like Louis XVI.

Posted by: ® at September 13, 2010 04:58 PM (Gr1V1)

58 Standing all Proud of his Dad who won the Silver Star in the Army.

Posted by: Racefan at September 13, 2010 04:58 PM (L4ZSk)

59 I hate that fucking communist Martha Raddich chick though. She is a absolute leftist.

She looked like she was swallowing a case of lemons when she asked him what he was fighting for.

Posted by: Soap MacTavish at September 13, 2010 05:00 PM (554T5)

60 #63 We ask you do not imply any act involving us, and swallowing, with Martha Raddich.

Posted by: Case of Lemons at September 13, 2010 05:01 PM (Gr1V1)

61 #59

Oh and by the way, I got to hold his DFC medal.  It was SOOO cool!

This guy retire B Gen at 40 something.  Now works at Ft Bragg for some government agency, hmm, wonder what that could be??

Posted by: Kemp at September 13, 2010 05:04 PM (AQxTm)

62 61 Sometimes I go over to the green room just to beat up libtards. It's like Kos-lite.

Posted by: dagny at September 13, 2010 05:04 PM (VneYc)

63 I personally know a Distinguished Flying Cross recipient, the second highest award in the AF. No. The DFC is not really a medal for valour, nor is it the second highest award for the Air Force. That would be the Air Force Cross. All of the services may award the DFC for distinguished achievement in flight. The DFC was originally awarded in peacetime (and still can be).

Posted by: XBradTC at September 13, 2010 05:07 PM (X0Ona)

64 I'll bet it pained Raddich to no end to have to be in the same room with a warrior.

Posted by: Soap MacTavish at September 13, 2010 05:08 PM (554T5)

65 Gucci Shoes now produces flavor styles of shoes, loafers, clogs, and boots ¨C and now even heels, Gucci Shoes have grown from the chief feature innate supplies and emphasizing durability, comfort, and strong feet, Gucci shoes for men makes men¡¯s and women¡¯s footwear. Having a group of high responsibility, especially inquiries department, authentic Gucci Shoes has put huge inquiries time studying how the time, Gucci changed by the recurring shock of daily walking and workmanship. Despite some worth issues over the person body is fitting a cult desired and is well on the person body. Sometimes mistaken for Birkenstocks, Discount Gucci Shoes will be assured that Gucci delivers the finest in value and operation. The self-proclaimed ¡°finest walking shoes in the world¡±, Gucci Shoes takes an international success. Gucci women boots are physiological footwear intended.

Posted by: cq at September 13, 2010 05:10 PM (q1vYw)

66 Obama has to salute him first, not the other way around.  SSGT Giunta can then take his sweet time returning his salute, all the while Obama has to hold it there.

Hehehehe....

Posted by: EC at September 13, 2010 05:11 PM (f4TZ2)

67 Well, believe it is time for me to take my tired very old ass on to bed. Night Morons, its about time for the "submorons" to come on board.

I'll catch 'm on the rebound in the morning.

Posted by: Vic at September 13, 2010 05:11 PM (/jbAw)

68 And he's a paratrooper, of course. 'No sky too high, no blast too fast, you call we fall.' I was lucky to be a paratrooper when I was young if only because it allowed me to meet genuine heroes. For example, my platoon sergeant, Sergeant First Class Raleigh May, was winner of the Distinguished Service Cross. Another thing: one of the reasons I love my country so much is that it manages to produce men like May and Giunta.

Posted by: troyriser at September 13, 2010 05:14 PM (mU1zA)

69 #71 see ya round ya crazy moron!

Posted by: CAC at September 13, 2010 05:16 PM (Gr1V1)

70 I saw this guy. God Bless Him.

O/t:  Devin nunes is on with batchelor, in studio.
He has the heavy hitters on the panel tonight and they will be discussing the election tomorrow.


Posted by: curious at September 13, 2010 05:17 PM (p302b)

71

Obama has to salute him first, not the other way around.  SSGT Giunta can then take his sweet time returning his salute, all the while Obama has to hold it there.

I'd love to be a fly on the wall so I could hear The Vapid One™ bitch about that little detail. Id even go so far as to bet that he wouldn't do it, seeing as how he hates the country and the military so much.

Heh, pix or it didn't happen...

Posted by: BackwardsBoy at September 13, 2010 05:33 PM (kFODZ)

72 Thank God for men like SSG Giunta and every warrior that swears to protect and defend our Constitution with their blood.

Posted by: MCPO Airdale at September 13, 2010 05:36 PM (G5qLy)

73 Congratulations and thank you to brave and courageous men like this as well as everyone else who serves.

Posted by: johnc_recent_EX-dem at September 13, 2010 05:36 PM (ACkhT)

74
I have no idea why the military has taken this approach to the Medal of Honor but it does the whole nation a disservice.

Maybe because they don't pass them out like donuts?

It sounds like this guy really earned the MOH and I'm glad he was awarded it.

The subject of military decorations can really piss people off.  My father was recommended for the Legion of Merit and his superior Officer ripped up the papers in front of him -- telling my father that because he didn't hold the Legion of Merit none of his subordinates would ever be awarded one.

That kind of shit makes my blood boil.

Posted by: Ed Anger at September 13, 2010 05:37 PM (7+pP9)

75 Ed, I don't think anyone is calling for the MoH to be passed out like donuts, but for a while there, the only way to earn it was to die tryin'. That's not how it's supposed to work. As for your father's LoM, that's fucked. But I've always thought most achievement awards were mostly fluff anyway. If it isn't an award for valor, it's just nice to have.

Posted by: XBradTC at September 13, 2010 05:41 PM (X0Ona)

76 I actually think it's a good idea to keep the Medal rare, so that those who do earn it are properly honored. In some past conflicts they passed them out like Crackerjack prizes. Check out the US-Korea conflict back in the 19th century; either that was the most badassed engagement in the history of warfare or there was some medal inflation going on.

Posted by: Trimegistus at September 13, 2010 05:42 PM (Xd1FX)

77 #67

I stand corrected.  Bosnia counts as peace time I guess?  He was a stealth fighter pilot.  It was still a cool medal.  Here is the list.

http://tinyurl.com/375fe7r

Posted by: Kemp at September 13, 2010 05:42 PM (AQxTm)

78 Kemp, Bosnia? It depends on when. I was imprecise. The DFC can be awarded either in peacetime or wartime. They don't hand 'em out like candy, but it ranks a couple steps down from the Air Force/Navy/Distinguished Service Cross.

Posted by: XBradTC at September 13, 2010 05:46 PM (X0Ona)

79 #83

1999.  The story I heard is that a F-117 was shot down by a random shot.  Only 2 F-117 have been lost, one in MD and this one in Bosnia. 

The story is the Chinese paid for everything they could get from the crash and it was at the embassy. Chinese are pretty good at reverse engineering. Some say a  B-2 took out the embassy, could be and my guy was cover, but I think a F-117 has enough to take out an embassy.

Just saying, the cover story, we had the wrong maps.  Yeah right.

Note the Chinese did not bitch at all.

Posted by: Kemp at September 13, 2010 05:59 PM (AQxTm)

80

also, the O'Donnell v. Castle fight just got more interesting.

Krauthammer called Demint and Palin's endorsement of O'Donnell destructive and irresponsible.

 

Posted by: Ben at September 13, 2010 08:31 PM (DKV43)

The commenters at Gateway Pundit are not amused.  The battle rages for anyone interested.

Posted by: RushBabe at September 13, 2010 05:59 PM (a3Z62)

81

As for your father's LoM, that's fucked. But I've always thought most achievement awards were mostly fluff anyway. If it isn't an award for valor, it's just nice to have.

Posted by: XBradTC at September 13, 2010 09:41 PM (X0Ona)

What's valor?

My father was the CO of one of the first assault helicopter battalions in Vietnam.

He had his D model stripped out and outfitted with a 40 mm grenade launcher chin turret, twin M-60s on the skids and  twin 2.75 FFAR launchers. Loaded for bear.

He never carried troops. He carried ammo, instead.

He was always the first one in and the last one out. And he never lost a chopper in his outfit when he was there.

Was that valorous?

Posted by: Ed Anger at September 13, 2010 06:03 PM (7+pP9)

82

1999.  The story I heard is that a F-117 was shot down by a random shot.  Only 2 F-117 have been lost, one in MD and this one in Bosnia. 

The story is the Chinese paid for everything they could get from the crash and it was at the embassy. Chinese are pretty good at reverse engineering. Some say a  B-2 took out the embassy, could be and my guy was cover, but I think a F-117 has enough to take out an embassy.

Just saying, the cover story, we had the wrong maps.  Yeah right.

Note the Chinese did not bitch at all.

Posted by: Kemp at September 13, 2010 09:59 PM (AQxTm)

The story at that time was that some French NATO Colonel leaked the route and TOT to the Bosnians so that when the F-117 opened its weapons bay doors it was a toasty target. IIRC the Freepers & WorldNutDaily (and even Drudge) pushed this scenario, so take it for what it's worth.

Posted by: Ed Anger at September 13, 2010 06:31 PM (7+pP9)

83 Was that valorous?

Posted by: Ed Anger at September 13, 2010 10:03 PM (7+pP9)

 

Thank you for his service!

Posted by: NC Ref at September 13, 2010 07:21 PM (S1dRE)

84 Ed Anger at 87 - IIRC the F117's followed the exact same attack route at least two (and possibly three) nights in a row. The goblins moved in a lot of guns and when spotters heard the engines opened up with everything, just putting up a random "wall of steel" in the projected flight path. Bringing down a modern jet is not hard if you put a round through a critical system.

Posted by: Have Blue at September 13, 2010 08:22 PM (mV+es)

85

World War I KIA: 116,708

World War I MoH recipients: 124 (rate: 1/968 KIAs)

World War II KIA: 416,800

World War II MoH recipients: 464 (1/900)

Korea KIA: 36,940

Korea MoH recipients: 133 (1/280)

Vietnam KIA: 58,236

Vietnam MoH recipients: 246 (1/237)

Iraq/Afghanistan KIA: 5,693

Iraq/Afghanistan MoH recipients: 7 (1/813)

Measured MoH's/KIA, they have been issued at roughly the same rate (higher actually) as they were in WW1 & 2, but significantly lower than they were in Vietnam and Korea. Medical care has improved dramatically, even since the last 2 wars, so that would suggest that it should be closer to the Korea/Vietnam rates, since fewer wounded servicemen are dying from infections or for want of access to treatment. But then many of the deaths have been caused by circumstances not allowing for much heroism, such as IED explosions.

All that assumes that there should be any correlation between KIAs and the number of MoH recipients.

My personal opinion, with no evidence whatsoever to support it, is that the MoH is being withheld to some degree because they're keeping the standards unreasonably high and because a living MoH recipient could become a political liability, if he chose to criticize the war effort or a particular political party.

I also suspect, also with no evidence to back me up whatsoever, that the 20+ MoHs awarded to 442nd RCT vets were driven by politics as much as by genuine heroism. Looking back at the war from 50 years later it's easy to consider "heroic" acts that other units routinely witnessed, that were not, unlike the 442nd, reconsidered for the MoH 50 years after the fact. In addition, according to Band of Brothers and other books, there was actually a cap placed on the number of MoHs that could be issued per division for any given action. For example, MoHs were limited to one per division for the Normandy invasion.

Posted by: Wilkey at September 13, 2010 08:46 PM (tBrQI)

86 One other thing. If you read MOH citations from WWII or Korea, many were given for the act of killing large numbers of enemy soldiers. I remember the citation for one Marine who stayed at a forward location on a ridge in the face of a Japanese attack and used, among other things, a .50 caliber machine gun to kill the enemy with flanking fire as they advanced. His citation credits him with killing "hundreds" of enemy soldiers and breaking the back of the attack.

Most of the citations I have seen from both Iraq and the 'stans were awarded for heroic actions taken to save fellow soldiers.

Of course no one proposed medals for "restraint" during WWII either.

Posted by: Have Blue at September 13, 2010 09:08 PM (mV+es)

87 All-

Those of you stuck on the rank abbreviations take a pill.  AP Stylebook makes the rank abbreviations different than the services do, that's all.  He may have been using that, or had some experience with the AP way.  I know, I know, it sucks, but, as a Public Affairs officer, AND someone in service for 30 years, we deal with it on a daily basis...

Wolf

Posted by: Mr Wolf at September 13, 2010 09:40 PM (qGuG3)

88 I'm not a big fan of the idea of Presidents saluting. I was OK with Bush doing it because back in the day some E-6 showed him how. Obama'd probably fuck it up and embarrass everyone. Let him soothe his ego by hiding behind civilian control of the military.

Posted by: Jeff Gauch at September 13, 2010 11:16 PM (CO/RA)

89

The main reference Fleetguard filter as below:

LF3000 LF3325 LF670 LF777 LF9009 LF9001 LF9000 LF3349 LF3345 LF9024 FS1212 FS1280 FS1000 FS1006 FF105 FF202 FF5052 FS1251 WF2054 K2139 AF891 LF3325 LF16011 LF16034 FS19594 FS1003 FS1022 WF2075 WF2071 WF2076 FS1040 WF2126 AH1100 AH1101 AH1103 AH1135 AF947 AF1969M AF1850 AF4548 AF928 AF872 AH1183 AF25278 AF25708 AF25593 AF1811 AF1638 FS1251 LF16015 FF5485 FF5488 FS19816 FS19816 FF105D FS1235 FS1240 FS1242 MF723 MF2073 FF108 FF5317 FS19732 FS19789 HF35139 FF5327 LF691 FS19532 FS20000 LF3970 FF5421 AF928M AF472 AF872M WF2074 WF2073 FF2010 FF2020 WF2072 AF4553M AF4554M AF890 LF3959 FS19584 HF6555
If you can not find the part number you need,please contact us,we will give you reply in one workday.
Email:sales@parts-china.com;info@parts-china.com;support@parts-china.com

 

Posted by: Darren at September 14, 2010 12:16 AM (LtxF8)

90 There are a few things to keep in mind about the Medal:

-Before WWII, there were far fewer awards in existence. The Medal was used as a generic recognition of valor. WWII resulted in the creation of more awards, and the Medal was singled out as something special.

-The Medal tends to be awarded on missions that can be discussed publicly. If you can't talk about a mission because of classification issues, or because of the risk of compromise of ongoing operations, the Medal will have to wait.

-If you are going to be nominated by somebody in your chain of command, an officer has to have witnessed the action. If nobody of appropriate rank is around to see what you did, you will probably be nominated for a Silver Star rather than the Medal. Modern warfare involves a lot of smaller, more-dispersed groups of people and urban combat, which make witnessing such acts difficult.



Posted by: Heinlein Libertarian at September 14, 2010 05:02 AM (AcKBw)

91 Thank you for your service Staff Sergeant Giunta.God bless you and your family. I have a seasonal neighbor who is a Medal of Honor recipient from Korea, Corporal Dwane Dewey, USMC.I have the utmost respect for him.Good News for you Sal, the nightmares and bad memories tend to fade after 20 years or so.Semper Fi, God bless the 173rd Airborne.

Posted by: John Harris at September 20, 2010 04:55 AM (FOdHt)

92

I know or served with three Medal of Honor Marines. Robert O'Malley, William Raymond Prom and Dwaine Williams. O'Malley served with India Company 3rd Battalion 3rd Regiment 3rd Marine Division and awarded the Medal for action on the 18 Aug 1965. Still living, only one of 87.

Prom was a fellow machine gunner, we served together and he was killed on the 9 Feb 1969.

Williams was a classmate who quite school and joined the Marines. He was killed on his birthday 6 months into his tour.

We honor those who served and gave their lives so others may live.

Posted by: Rex McBee USMC at November 17, 2010 05:05 AM (qkBNo)

93

 It is my pleasure to read this page,I look forward to reading more

this our web site welcome http://www.haffr.com/vb/

http://www.haffr.com

Posted by: fares at February 05, 2011 10:02 PM (Yp3YQ)

Hide Comments | Add Comment | Refresh | Top

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
129kb generated in CPU 0.0352, elapsed 0.2058 seconds.
64 queries taking 0.1821 seconds, 221 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.