March 15, 2010

The Problem With Heartbreaking Health-Care Anecdotes
— Dave in Texas

Actually I don't think it's a problem at all really, it's not the facts that surface from the story, it's the telling of the tale that accomplishes its purpose.

Still, dude.

Natoma Canfield, the cancer-stricken woman who has become a centerpiece of President ObamaÂ’s push for health care reform, will not lose her home over her medical bills and will probably qualify for financial aid, a top official at the Cleveland medical center treating her told FoxNews.com.

Though Canfield’s sister Connie Anderson said her sibling is afraid she’ll lose her house and Obama warned at an Ohio rally Monday that the patient is “racked with worry” about the cost of tests and treatment, she is already being screened for financial help.

Lyman Sornberger, executive director of patient financial services at the Cleveland Clinic, said “all indications” at the outset are that she will be considered for assistance.

“She may be eligible for state Medicaid … and/or she will be eligible for charity (care) of some form or type. … In my personal opinion, she will be eligible for something,” he said, adding that Canfield should not be worried about losing her home.

“Cleveland Clinic will not put a lien on her home,” he said.

Funny how he screws up "need health insurance right now" when he meant "need health insurance reform right now". Stupid TOTUS.

I don't think Obama's team is so dumb they don't know this. They just don't care. She's a prop.

Think about that context. The current "system" cares a hell of a lot more about Natoma's well-being than Obama does.

h/t Carin, or Car in. The space means something but I'm an idiot and I don't remember things so good.

Posted by: Dave in Texas at 06:37 PM | Comments (108)
Post contains 296 words, total size 2 kb.

1

He must be insinuating that we must act now or she will die. 

Hey.  I say we call her bluff.

Posted by: Hussein the Plumber at March 15, 2010 06:40 PM (r1h5M)

2 Who is it exploiting fear, again?

Posted by: nickless at March 15, 2010 06:41 PM (MMC8r)

3 Like every example they bring up, once you dig into it, it's total BS.

I was related how someone was not denied service, but was billed becuase she forgot here insurance card. So, hey let's take over 1/6 the US economy. The idiots are in charge.

Posted by: Mike H at March 15, 2010 06:41 PM (zqzYV)

4 Bitch, he won't even remember your name when you're wearing his T-shirt in your casket.

Posted by: Tattoo De Plane at March 15, 2010 06:43 PM (mHQ7T)

5 You know what, fuck this shit, what's up my brothers!!

Posted by: CDR M at March 15, 2010 06:45 PM (WGN3u)

6 She'll remember I think.   If not, report!!

Posted by: CDR M at March 15, 2010 06:45 PM (WGN3u)

7 So, now Toyotas cause cancer, too?

Posted by: eman at March 15, 2010 06:48 PM (xJwcz)

8 Why is it, when I'm out walking my dog after watching yet another example of Washington's corruption, incompetence and contempt for our freedoms, I see every telephone poll as a potential gibbet?

Posted by: effinayright at March 15, 2010 06:50 PM (eDLXV)

9 As I said to my crazy leftist co-worker who was yelling at me because I did not support the current 'legislation':  "You don't get to take over  1/6 of the US economy because your cousin, sister, mother, brother, friend (fill in the blank) is afflicted with cancer, MS, has a broken leg, has athsma, (fill in the blank).
Why do they insist that there is a one size fits all solution (bigger gubmint) to all these specific individual problems?

Posted by: Chesty Puller at March 15, 2010 06:51 PM (hyvSd)

10 If the Dem's go sans constitution on this bill Natona's end is inconsequential. To pass this bill at this juncture is a declaration of war on the American public.

Posted by: mghorning at March 15, 2010 06:51 PM (9tt2f)

11 off damn sock!

Posted by: muggedbyrealty at March 15, 2010 06:52 PM (hyvSd)

12 Um, they can pass it tomorrow but it doesn't start for what 4 years? So she can pay taxes for govt healthcare and hope to live that long?

Posted by: dagny at March 15, 2010 06:56 PM (UERLl)

13 It wasn't Obama exploiting this woman, it was the Fright Wing Death Marchers from Fox.

Posted by: dagny at March 15, 2010 06:57 PM (UERLl)

14

“She may be eligible for state Medicaid … and/or she will be eligible for charity (care) of some form or type. … In my personal opinion, she will be eligible for something,” he said, adding that Canfield should not be worried about losing her home.

“Cleveland Clinic will not put a lien on her home,”

That's all good and well, but what would have happened had she not shown up in Obama's speech?

“Cleveland Clinic will not put a lien on her home,”

Great, but what if she was getting treatment somewhere else? Not all cancer treatment facilities are that magnanimous, and even if they were, the money is still coming from somewhere. The only real discussion we are having at this point is: does the cost come from column "A" or column "B".

Posted by: Jim in San Diego at March 15, 2010 06:59 PM (F09Uo)

15 oops, forgot.

Posted by: CDR M at March 15, 2010 06:59 PM (WGN3u)

16 Going with what dagney says in #12 - I heard again today that 44,000 uninsured people die each day in America..blah blah blah.  That's a lot of people they are going to let die between now and when this phoneyassed bill kicks in.  If it's such a great concern..........

Posted by: prettypinkfluffypanties at March 15, 2010 07:02 PM (JPFLH)

17 Every poster child for health care reform has been a fraud.
Every single one.

Posted by: Richard Aubrey at March 15, 2010 07:03 PM (e2Npe)

18 I'm confused here. If she was going to die if she didn't get treatment now, how will Obamacare help her if it isn't implemented until 2013?

Posted by: mrcaniac at March 15, 2010 07:04 PM (Vol3D)

19 Someone on Talk Radio this morning was calling this Obama's "nuclear anecdote", which I thought was kinda funny (but the pathetic health bill ain't funny at all).  I'm with Dagny--if this bill is so all-fired important NOW, why doesn't it go into effect (I mean insure anyone) for 4 years?  In the meantime, the private sector will help Ms. Canfield get state-of-the-art care at The Cleveland Clinic; one of the reasons she will get that care is because those EVIL insurance companies pay more to the Cleveland Clinic then the govmint programs of Medicare and Medicaid do.  This is a bizarre system in some ways, but it is beyond me why anyone thinks increasing government involvement is going to fix anything.

Posted by: Janemarie at March 15, 2010 07:07 PM (3GUrQ)

20 I have a pretty cozy relationship with the Cleveland Clinic. They have a fellow there who can remove almost any organ in the human body through an invisible puncture next to the navel. Critics would be well advised not to fuck with them.  

Posted by: comatus at March 15, 2010 07:07 PM (/VEEI)

21 Comatus,

Does he remove feet and tonsils also?

Posted by: mrcaniac at March 15, 2010 07:09 PM (Vol3D)

22 Remember that soldier pic I posted about using human shields? 

The broader concept applies outside the military as well in all aspects of daily life.  Obama is using human shields.  Most slimy politicians do.

Posted by: Purple Avenger at March 15, 2010 07:10 PM (Wj4bl)

23 It's no different from when Social Security was on the table.  The Dems would trot out a bluehair who lamented that, if those eeeevil republicans took away her check, she'd starve!

Posted by: The Sanit Inspector at March 15, 2010 07:11 PM (ykuYp)

24 I'm listening to Paul Ryan on Cspan.  Wow, that guy must have a hell of a time walking.  Clang, Clang......

Posted by: prettypinkfluffypanties at March 15, 2010 07:19 PM (JPFLH)

25

Obama has an anecdote for all that ails you.

Posted by: kansas at March 15, 2010 07:21 PM (34yXu)

26 Vote for Obamacare so Christopher Reeve's corpse will walk again!

Posted by: TexasJew at March 15, 2010 07:21 PM (HzNcF)

27 Every great social crime has its origin in altruism, or the pretense thereof.

Posted by: rawmuse at March 15, 2010 07:23 PM (f8RLN)

28

Remember Harry Reid's little friend "Timmy" (or whatever) whom he said was "scared" during the Shamnesty debacle? What a load of bullcrap.

These motherfuckers always "find" - ie, INVENT - some weepy imaginary friend to torture us with while they pick our pockets and fuck up our nation.

And we are supposed to listen to this drivel like idiot children....

 

 

Posted by: TexasJew at March 15, 2010 07:28 PM (HzNcF)

29 Once i was so sick, and without proper coverage, because of the evil George Bush. I was so sick I had to use the dick of a dead donkey when I wanted to have sex. But I was banging hippy chicks, so the smell of the dead dick was masked by their body odor, and they thought it was a very earth friendly solution, and quite the turn-on. Still, I can't help but think, if I had health care, I could have used my own dick, and scored a better grade of skank, like maybe chicks who could afford razor blades, and deodorant. Passing O-care will mean no one will ever have to suffer like this, and it will create 11-ty bazillion new jobs, and $100 bills will fall from the sky, and my Unicorn will be happy again. So please, for me, for the children, for my Unicorn: pass O-care. Gaia will weep with joy. Now who wants to give me a tit wank?

Posted by: KilltheHippies at March 15, 2010 07:29 PM (VKfXw)

30 Lucky for her, she doesn't have tonsil or foot cancer.

Posted by: TexasJew at March 15, 2010 07:29 PM (HzNcF)

31 If I were a physician, I'd burn those pimple-faced medical students and government and academic "doctors" who comprise the now-tiny membership of the shriveled leftwing AMA to the fucking ground.

Posted by: TexasJew at March 15, 2010 07:33 PM (HzNcF)

32 What really is the heart breaker are the heaps of rotting dead bodies stacked outside hospitals, where these poor bastards where turned away from healthcare.  Yea, it's an awful sight, and the stench is enough to knock you to your knees.  It's a national disgrace for sure.

Posted by: Dr. Bugnuts at March 15, 2010 07:33 PM (r0u40)

33 If we had passed Obamacare, Elizabeth Edwards would still be alive!

Posted by: TexasJew at March 15, 2010 07:36 PM (HzNcF)

34 I don't think I've ever seen such a look of misery and dejection on the face of my daughter as I just did a moment ago.

I sat down with her on the sofa and (as calmly as I could) tried to explain to her why the Senate Republicans want to keep her, a diabetic, club-footed, cancer-stricken, cleft-lipped, hermaphrodite with lyme's disease, from getting health insurance. I tried to keep my voice steady, but it became increasingly difficult - the rage and feelings of helplessnes were just too much.

I think my daughter could tell something was wrong. I found myself at such a loss for words - nothing made any sense; nothing makes sense anymore. I finally had to admit, "Honey, I just don't know - I don't know what's going on in this country anymore..."

When I finished her lower lip started to tremble and her eyes began to fill with tears, "Daddy" she said, "why are the Republicans doing this to the country?" Well, that was it for me: I finally fell apart. She just fell into my arms and we both began sobbing for several minutes.

True story.

Posted by: CheChe at March 15, 2010 07:38 PM (EW49d)

35 I'm calling this thread for TexasJew.

Posted by: Tattoo De Plane at March 15, 2010 07:40 PM (mHQ7T)

36 If we don't pass ObamaCare every American will die someday. Of death and related complications.

Posted by: eman at March 15, 2010 07:41 PM (xJwcz)

37

True story.

Posted by: CheChe at March 15, 2010 11:38 PM (EW49d)

As a concerned life-long republican, I want to tell you how concerned I am about your daughter, and all the daughters that us life-long republicans are so concerned about.

Posted by: TexasJew at March 15, 2010 07:41 PM (HzNcF)

38

If we don't pass Obamacare, I will continue to spew my vile stupidity on MSNBC.

And I don't think anyone wants that, do they?

Posted by: Keith Olbermann at March 15, 2010 07:43 PM (EW49d)

39 I was recently diagnosed with Acute Concernicemia. My Doctor said it was nothing. I know he's lying.

Posted by: eman at March 15, 2010 07:45 PM (xJwcz)

40 Notice you haven't seen the Lace Wig guy around lately? He died. No health care. He could have been saved. The good news is he was buried in a replica handbag.

Posted by: KilltheHippies at March 15, 2010 07:47 PM (VKfXw)

41 ERs are filling up with unicorns strung out on meth and My Little Pony dust.

Posted by: eman at March 15, 2010 07:49 PM (xJwcz)

42

You bastards.  You slimy bastards.  If only you hadn't delayed Obamacare....

I fucking hate you all.

Posted by: Peter Graves at March 15, 2010 07:51 PM (EW49d)

43 Funny how he screws up "need health insurance right now" when he meant "need health insurance reform right now". Stupid TOTUS.

I don't think Obama's team is so dumb they don't know this. They just don't care. She's a prop.


Beg to disagree who is the "prop" here.

As much as we all enjoy our mid and high school history lessons and those ancient tales of jack-booted thugs, authoritarians, genocidal madmen, etc. Some stories so ancient that they seem to date back to our own Grandparents recollections...

The "prop" here is "health insurance reform".

Our own ancient Grandparents would see this as it were yesterday; with half denouncing it as an obvious enslavement of 1/6th the population with a boot on the neck of the rest; with the other half of our Grandfathers demanding their  share of the greedy filthy rich jew's ill gotten gain.

Barry know his community organizing.

Posted by: Druid at March 15, 2010 07:52 PM (Gct7d)

44 Why do these stories just encourage me to keep smoking?

Posted by: unknown jane at March 15, 2010 07:55 PM (5/yRG)

45 O/T:  Crazy stuff on Zero Hedge today.

Posted by: curious at March 15, 2010 07:58 PM (p302b)

46

Did anyone else see Nightline tonight?  I would have sworn that they used stock footage to make it appear that BamBam had a larger crowd today than was reported on the Conservative sites.  I heard that he was lucky to get 200 folks today, but they were showing scenes from a high school gymnasium.  It sure looked like 2 different crowds.

They wouldn't do something underhanded like that, would they?  I mean, they wouldn't be trying to make it look like little Barry isn't losing his touch, right? 

Oh wait...

Posted by: Teresa in Fort Worth, TX at March 15, 2010 07:58 PM (PTUpr)

47 re: #39 -- "New Christian Louboutin spring shoes are hitting the shelves" All because they don't have O-care. So sad, so true. (Just out of curiousity, WTF is a spring shoe? Is that to make you extra light in the loafers, or what exactly?)

Posted by: KilltheHippies at March 15, 2010 08:00 PM (VKfXw)

48 Gabe? Wanna field this one?

Posted by: richard mcenroe at March 15, 2010 08:03 PM (66IP+)

49

appealing to sentiment to persuade doesnt work -

see 'the art of war'. and oh yeah -

Our we mixing DPS and None DPS row's, and who is the watch dog?

?

 

Posted by: Otis Mathis at March 15, 2010 08:04 PM (8QNN9)

50 I was reading over at the Greenroom, and too solace from the fact that:

In other words, ObamaCare is just one vote shy of defeat in the House… with 70 votes still up for grabs. We must win over one more Democrat — before they win over 70: If Democrats lose even one more congressman, the bill dies.

Actually, what I really took solace from was the realization that it's actually worse for Pelosi and the Demoncrats that so many House Members have not announced their vote; because Pelosi can't tell which of the 70 need to be bribed.

Posted by: ParisParamus at March 15, 2010 08:04 PM (TFs5o)

51 OT, sorry, but is Dick Armey a dick, or am I just taking his Tea Party screed the wrong way?  I've never paid much attention to him before.

Posted by: prettypinkfluffypanties at March 15, 2010 08:08 PM (JPFLH)

52 31 If I were a physician, I'd burn those pimple-faced medical students and government and academic "doctors" who comprise the now-tiny membership of the shriveled leftwing AMA to the fucking ground.

Posted by: TexasJew at March 15, 2010 11:33 PM (HzNcF)

Does anyone here know what role the AMA plays in the number of med students admitted and the number of accredited med schools there are in the U.S.?

If you are working this problem from a supply and demand standpoint, I'd think about that first.

Posted by: Jim in San Diego at March 15, 2010 08:14 PM (F09Uo)

53 the health care system in america is in much better shape than i thought.  i'd already dismissed all these folks categorically since the plight of one individual (however sad) is not a persuasive argument to overhaul national policy.  however, the fact that he can't find one legit hard luck case is pretty astounding.  i mean, they have 44,000 chances a day; just grab one of those suckers who's dying from lack of health insurance and tell the crowd, "this suckers gonna die today cuz he has no health care.  and so will 43,999 others like him!"

Posted by: Contributor X at March 15, 2010 08:16 PM (UsHD8)

54 I received a letter today, actually, uh, my staff handed me a letter, from, uh, a Louis Vuitton. He said that he was, uh, just planning for a wedding and looking for a jolt of fun when he got sick, and uh, couldn't afford healthcare. Spring was on the way, and he had many faves. True story.

Posted by: Hussein at March 15, 2010 08:19 PM (5I0Yr)

55 What about Invisible Rabbit Care? Huh? Huh?

You can stuff Osama Obama in a Louis Vuitton bag, but we Invisible Rabbits need gubmint assistance too, and we breed! Like rabbits, y'know....

And unlike Democrats, who shit on everyone, we leave tiny pellets behind.

Posted by: Harvey at March 15, 2010 08:22 PM (HVU/R)

56 We'd better pass ObamaCare now, otherwise many, many Americans will find that their car insurance has been canceled!  It happened to me back in Chicago when I was a poor university student and couldn't afford full coverage.  Incidentally, my poor roommate was worried about his mother because she was going to lose her house to pay for treatment when she had a really, really, really bad hangnail. 

Posted by: Metaphorsinablender at March 15, 2010 08:23 PM (iGCmo)

57

Here's the rest of the story.  This woman is now in her 50's. She was diagnosed in her 30's.  She either quit or was laid off her job and has been unemployed for 12 years.  The house she is so worried about losing was her parents.  It's a mystery to me how someone can be without gainful employment for 12 years and not have lost the house long before that.

 

She was unemployed for 12 years but managed to make 5,000$/year in health insurance payments.  When it went up to $8,000/year, she dropped it.

 

The human prop is somewhat of a sham.

 

Details at gateway pundit.

Posted by: koz at March 15, 2010 08:24 PM (RpKLP)

58 The system still needs reform. In fact, uh, I received a letter today from, uh, a constituent who got his balls stuck in a pudding cup.

Posted by: ObamaCare Failure Speech Excerpt at March 15, 2010 08:32 PM (5I0Yr)

59 O/T: Am I the only one who gets the irony of President Daddy Issues doing those fatherhood PSAs?

Posted by: AmishDude at March 15, 2010 08:35 PM (Vo2Ef)

60 What mutation of stupid makes possible such a flimsy "example-victim"?  Why not find someone, SOMEONE in genuine need of better insurance.  What are your theories on this?  Is he just trying to expend out energy as we investigate, discover, and then comment on how STUPID he and his administration is?  I just don't get his MO....ideas?

Posted by: ParisParamus at March 15, 2010 08:41 PM (TFs5o)

61 Arguments of "aggregate by anecdote" are for the simple-minded, at best.  This is about the best level that Mr. "reduce health insurance premiums by 3000%" and "profit and earnings ratios" can ever hope to achieve.

Why can't someone just ask the Indonesian Imbecile what the "profit and earnings ratios" of the private health insurance companies are, and what they would be with premiums reduced 3000%?

Posted by: progressoverpeace at March 15, 2010 08:41 PM (A46hP)

62 These Dems think they can cheat Death. They think they can change the weather. They even think that John Edwards is teh hawt.

Posted by: rawmuse at March 15, 2010 08:43 PM (f8RLN)

63

16  55 Going with what dagney says in #12 - I heard again today that 44,000 uninsured people die each day in America..blah blah blah. 

Can we talk?

44,000 people dying a DAY would mean that 16 MILLION Americans die every year from being uninsured.

Yes, the Obamacare zealots are idiots.   But the (stupid and bogus) Harvard study where the 44,000 number came up claimed 44,000 per year.

Lets not take stupidity to the nth power.

 

 

 

 

Posted by: effinayright at March 15, 2010 08:45 PM (eDLXV)

64

And remember that piece of shit bill they're talking about won't go into effect until, what, 2013.  Which means that chances are this lady will be gone from this world way before the bill even takes effect.

Posted by: experience smeperience at March 15, 2010 08:52 PM (8mpdw)

65

44,000 people dying a DAY would mean that 16 MILLION Americans die every year from being uninsured. 

Meh.  Numbers are meaningless to leftists ... and The Precedent can't understand much past three digits, himself.  Heck, what's the difference whether 10,000 died in the tornado or just 12?  It's just numbers ... 'They cut your feet off for "30,000 ... 40,000 ... even $50,000" - because they get paid on time for that' ... what's the big deal if it's only around $1,000?  They're just numbers.  Don't be so culturally oppressive.  Empathy is what matters ... not numbers ... not laws ...

Yes, the Obamacare zealots are idiots.   But the (stupid and bogus) Harvard study where the 44,000 number came up claimed 44,000 per year.

Posted by: effinayright at March 16, 2010 12:45 AM (eDLXV)


That's around the same number who die on the roads.  Government drivers for everyone!  Only the government can be trusted with the responsibilities of driving!

Posted by: progressoverpeace at March 15, 2010 08:53 PM (A46hP)

66 I have taken to chewing my toes violently. It is my art. Yes I am a performance artist. I got one toe off last week. The second of my remaining nine toes will be off shortly. I need Obamacare NOW or I will have at least 2 or more blue detached toes that it will be too late to sew back on. You see, I need taxpayers to pay for the restoration of my toes over and over into the future, so that I can continue to pursue my art full-time. Just as the Speaker of the House of the United States Congress says that I can after Obamacare.

Posted by: Geekert Mapplethorpe at March 15, 2010 08:55 PM (OaRvZ)

67 Er ... I meant:

44,000 people dying a DAY would mean that 16 MILLION Americans die every year from being uninsured. 

Meh.  Numbers are meaningless to leftists ... and The Precedent can't understand much past three digits, himself.  Heck, what's the difference whether 10,000 died in the tornado or just 12?  It's just numbers ... 'They cut your feet off for "30,000 ... 40,000 ... even $50,000" - because they get paid on time for that' ... what's the big deal if it's only around $1,000?  They're just numbers.  Don't be so culturally oppressive.  Empathy is what matters ... not numbers ... not laws ...

Yes, the Obamacare zealots are idiots.   But the (stupid and bogus) Harvard study where the 44,000 number came up claimed 44,000 per year.

Posted by: effinayright at March 16, 2010 12:45 AM (eDLXV)


That's around the same number who die on the roads.  Government drivers for everyone!  Only the government can be trusted with the responsibilities of driving!

Posted by: progressoverpeace at March 15, 2010 08:55 PM (A46hP)

68

" But the (stupid and bogus) Harvard study where the 44,000 number came up claimed 44,000 per year. "

 

And 20 bucks says they would have died anyway even if they had health insurance.  People die.  It's what we do.

Posted by: experience smeperience at March 15, 2010 08:55 PM (8mpdw)

69 Sorry.  This text box keeps lying to my eyes about the formatting.  I'll have to do the html myself next time.

Posted by: progressoverpeace at March 15, 2010 08:56 PM (A46hP)

70 70 - 

"44,000 people dying a DAY would mean that 16 MILLION Americans die every year from being uninsured. "

Which would explain why we're making the point that if this were the case, why no need for urgency.

"Lets not take stupidity to the nth power."

You do realize I was quoting liberals, right?....not quoting what I perceive to be actual facts.  But...thanks for the "talk". 


Posted by: prettypinkfluffypanties at March 15, 2010 08:59 PM (JPFLH)

71 OT: Hillbuzz:     Subject:     [New post] Why is there a picture of Karl Marx hidden on this apple in the latest Newsweek cover of our fashion icon First Lady?
http://tinyurl.com/yc9q6dg

Posted by: ParisParamus at March 15, 2010 09:07 PM (TFs5o)

72 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FqX43ry5Bqk&feature=player_embedded Support the Tea Party candidate on March 23rd

Posted by: Mel at March 15, 2010 09:08 PM (RmUwq)

73 72 44,000 people dying a DAY would mean that 16 MILLION Americans die every year from being uninsured. ---------- so... you're saying the 30 million uninsured will cease to be a problem before Obamacare kicks in? status quo solves?

Posted by: Anachronda at March 15, 2010 09:18 PM (LD+ZJ)

74

Quick, everybody, itÂ’s presidential quiz time!  In this momentous week of historic proportions, hereÂ’s your pop quiz to see if youÂ’ve been paying attention. 

 

Ready?  Here we go!  Just fill in the blanks:

 

President _______, a former professorÂ… insisted he alone represented all the people.   However, he was often seen as arrogant and was criticized for moving too far ahead of popular opinion.   President ________ tried to build a popular mandate for ___________ by going on a nationwide speaking tour.

 

Fareed Zakaria: “It was too little, too late.  After president ________ had been unconcerned about public opinion, unconcerned about the senateÂ’s opinion, he then goes on this last desperate attempt to rally the public.  But in many ways the public felt he hadnÂ’t been talking to themÂ…  The senate was incensed that he was trying to do an end-run around them, and so the whole thing collapsed in failure. 

 

“President ____________ is a perfect example of a leader who perhaps was too aloof and too determined he going to lead, (and) forgot he had to take the country with him.”

 

 

 

 

Ok, howÂ’d you do?  Did you guess “president Wilson” and “AmericaÂ’s entry into the league of nations?”  Great, you got it right!

 

If you guessed “president Obama” and “healthcare reform,” they stay tuned and see if history repeats itself.

 

The above was taken verbatim from:

 

Mandate: The President and the People

Narrated by veteran CBS News correspondent Lesley Stahl, Mandate examines the long and complex relationship between the presidency and public opinion. Leading historians, political scientists, and public figures offer insight into presidents and the presidency from George Washington through FDR. Length: 35 min. 2005.  A project of the Annenberg Foundation Trust.

Posted by: Pike Place Pete at March 15, 2010 09:22 PM (MzTRc)

75 Republican can destroy the health care reform bill right now; if they will stress this message: By immediately raising taxes, this bill will sink our already struggling economy.


If media-prominent Republicans will emphasize that single crystallized point, the political pressure on wavering Democrats in the House to vote no will increase enormously. Factually, the bill legislates massive new taxes on personal incomes and on medical devices and services: all of which go into effect immediately upon the bill's passage. RAISING TAXES DURING A RECESSION will obviously hurt the economy. (Which is why Democrats have not dared attempt a tax increase despite controlling both chambers of congress.) So as unpopular at this ugly bill already is, it can be made much more so with simple clarion emphasis regarding what is sure to be its immediate destructiveness to the American economy.


The American people already hate what the bill stands for (the rotten substance of the bill) as well as they hate the corrupt process that has produced it. Now it needs to be branded into the national psyched that the passage of the bill will straightaway cause personal financial harm to everyone. The ball game will be over if Republicans will simply apply immense pressure to that one crippling point. (They can use the new CBO numbers coming out on the reconciliation/fix-it bill as a fresh predicate to sound the alarm.) There is simply no way Pelosi can secure wavering votes in the House if the Republicans drive home the message that this bill is instant poison to our ailing economy. Imagine multiple variations of the following sound bite issued from Republican after Republican: "If the Health Care Takeover Bill becomes law, our taxes immediately go up, and it will make of the worst recessions we've ever experienced much worse. Everyone knows you don't raise taxes during a recession."


Note that this is not the same as arguing that the added deficits this bill is certain to generate will be unsustainable in the long run. That's the "Generational Theft" message which has been lucidly conveyed and has resonated with the American public.- Severe concern has been raised... about the future. But the argument that the bill will also do serious harm to TODAY'S jobs and to TODAY'S fragile economy has yet to be forcefully made. - And this is the checkmate move that needs to be made here at the endgame this week.

Posted by: Dave at March 15, 2010 09:39 PM (dYwM1)

76

Obama's plans for health care make Mega-shark's air liner attacks look practical. This is the problem with electing bullshitters who have never actually done ANYTHING at all ever during their lives.

Posted by: Have Blue at March 15, 2010 10:26 PM (mV+es)

77 Honest question here (or maybe 4). So, the options?

Sit and take it and hope that a spineless repub party can do anything to block this (their records sure looks good on this stuff, heh)? Then another nail in this country's coffin.

How many more bills, stakes in the heart can this country take?

And the bonus question that usually gets rode out of thread on a rail.

When does this mean actual, unmitigated war-to save this country if that is even possible at this point? And for that matter, would a war just accelerate the inevitable?

 Inquiring minds want to know.


Posted by: jlfintx at March 15, 2010 11:13 PM (XIdMo)

78 81 OT: Hillbuzz:     Subject:     [New post] Why is there a picture of Karl Marx hidden on this apple in the latest Newsweek cover of our fashion icon First Lady?
http://tinyurl.com/yc9q6dg

Posted by: ParisParamus at March 16, 2010 01:07 AM (TFs5o)


That's a pic of the Wicked Witch and her poisoned apple. We're meant to be Snow White in this story.


On the topic headline..

Another prob with tugging at heart strings by politicos. I know I'm not the only one to have the knee jerk reaction of "hey boyo, I ain't your punk. Keep trying to play me and it's knuckle sandwich time."

Posted by: Grimmy at March 15, 2010 11:22 PM (yGyzx)

79 Anecdote?!  That sounds like one of those cable things.

Posted by: Charlie Gibson at March 16, 2010 12:18 AM (EVoH+)

80

why can this ahole post 20 lines of links but i get busted for posting a single tinyurl?

 

Posted by: Molon Labe at March 16, 2010 01:15 AM (kYpqT)

81 99

why can this ahole post 20 lines of links but i get busted for posting a single tinyurl?


Operator error?

Posted by: peanut gallery at March 16, 2010 02:01 AM (EVoH+)

82 Every poster child for health care reform has been a fraud.
Every single one.

Posted by: Richard Aubrey at March 15, 2010 11:03 PM (e2Npe)

Are you callin' me a liar, boy?  Goldangit after I get through makin' new rules to run roughshod over the Constytution, I'm gonna forgo mah dip in the cement pond and go find mah constititent who's usin' her kin's false teef and make a double-dog fool outta you.  Then we'll see who's the smartypants.

Posted by: Louise Slaughter (Hick-NY) at March 16, 2010 03:18 AM (ZxEhm)

83 Freakin' Al Gore is back! When will that guy go infront of a Judge?

Posted by: Mjim at March 16, 2010 04:09 AM (V8B//)

84 when works takes priority over snarking. That's crazy talk!

Posted by: Homer J. Burns at March 16, 2010 04:10 AM (SwkdU)

85

Good Morning Morons;

Fox is reporting thismorning two versions of the spin on healthcare. Obama and his commie minions are spewing that they have the votes and will vote on it this week.  Meanwhile someone else came on from the other side and said they only have 200 out of the 216 needed.

Who is right?  Well as I have been saying for months, when they have the votes they'l vote. 

Posted by: Vic at March 16, 2010 04:23 AM (QrA9E)

86 How about this story? My wife shifted out insurance from gold plated to catastrophic. We started taking really good care of ourselves, and didn't use the doctor that much. We saved over 200K over the past ten years and are using the money to put our kids through college. How about that one? We still have insurance when we get really sick too. I am self employed

Posted by: Jeff at March 16, 2010 04:23 AM (HScbI)

87

That's all good and well, but what would have happened had she not shown up in Obama's speech?

“Cleveland Clinic will not put a lien on her home,”

Great, but what if she was getting treatment somewhere else? Not all cancer treatment facilities are that magnanimous, and even if they were, the money is still coming from somewhere. The only real discussion we are having at this point is: does the cost come from column "A" or column "B".

Posted by: Jim in San Diego at March 15, 2010 10:59 PM

From their website...Cleveland Clinic is committed to providing world-class care to all patients regardless of ability to pay. Under its policies, Cleveland Clinic provides financial assistance to patients who do not have insurance coverage and who have family income levels up to four times the Federal Poverty Income Guidelines.

Patients who have insurance but still need assistance in payment for their medical services are also eligible for consideration.

This program is in addition to any patientÂ’s entitlement to free hospital care under the Ohio Hospital Care Assurance Program and includes Cleveland Clinic physician services. In the year 2005, the cost of hospital and physician charity care provided by the Cleveland Clinic Health System exceeded $100 million.

Posted by: Deanna at March 16, 2010 04:23 AM (JXlgX)

88 pass health care - for me!

Posted by: Teddy Kennedy's Alcohol-soaked corpse, burning in pit 6 for eternity at March 16, 2010 04:25 AM (27KAF)

Posted by: Mjim at March 16, 2010 04:29 AM (V8B//)

90 111 Obama caught lip-syncing! That's shameless.

Posted by: zombie Milli Vanilli at March 16, 2010 04:34 AM (SwkdU)

91 @112 ah ya, but whatcha gonna do.. Global warming made me do it

Posted by: Mjim at March 16, 2010 04:36 AM (V8B//)

92 this thread is almost as racist as those damned Japs in WW2.

Posted by: Tom Hanks at March 16, 2010 04:42 AM (QnUEJ)

93 I think they think that if they come up with just the right ancedote they will win the argument. It's the permanent campaign, they are trying find the Willie Lee Horton, Swift Boat, Daisy picking nuclear shot, Dukakis in a helmet moment.

Posted by: dagny at March 16, 2010 04:49 AM (2APed)

94

I got an idea,

Let's raise the abortion age from zero to 120. If you surpass your Obamacare allottment of say, $3k a year, you get in the abortion line then the government gets the OTHER 50% of your estate to pay for more abortions.

DO THE MATH PEOPLE, this WILL work.

Posted by: Grover at March 16, 2010 04:50 AM (gifD/)

95 As Jake Tapper so rightly pointed out, this bill would no abosutely NOTHING for this woman's condition.  In fact, the rationing of health care that will result will probably mean that the cost of helping this cancer stricken woman will outweigh the benefit of extending her life a year or two.  Remember:  the blue pill, red pill analogy that Obama used.  Moreover, the plan would do absolutely NOTHING for all of the other sob stories that Democrats keep yapping about.  What will it do? It will saddle our children with debt they can ill afford.  It will lead to rationing of health care most likely for all but those children and families of those passing this monstrosity. I am sickened by this whole thing.

Posted by: Stephen at March 16, 2010 05:04 AM (Q3eZI)

96 I am sickened by this whole thing.

Obama care can cure you...

Posted by: Mjim at March 16, 2010 05:06 AM (V8B//)

97 If you get 3000% of your premiums back then why can't you afford health care? or abortions? or whatever? You wouldn't even have to sell watermelons.

Posted by: dagny at March 16, 2010 05:08 AM (2APed)

98 Did Barry mention that she wants to be thrown out of her home while wearing an Obama t-shirt?

Posted by: TheQuietMan at March 16, 2010 05:10 AM (1Jaio)

99 I have been thinking about another way they can pass this trainwreck. After the elections, and the Democrat slaughter that will most likely follow, what will stop san fran nan from bringing the bill to the floor again and allowing those lame duck members from voting for it in essence sticking it to the constituents that just voted them out? And those that got re-elected are safe?

Posted by: TendStl at March 16, 2010 05:13 AM (CT5G+)

100 Actuallly, she would not have had her premiums raised due to previous illnesses. And I know 2 people who lost everything because of somewhat similar situations. Cancer hit them twice. In one case, the husband died and the wife lost the house. That's after paying insurance premiums for 30 years.

Posted by: Bill at March 16, 2010 05:14 AM (MN+T/)

101

Death and taxes are the only sure things in this world.

And the Dems are going to raise the tax rate & the death rate with just one bill.  Unprecedented.

Posted by: Speller at March 16, 2010 05:22 AM (o0R2E)

102 I'll say it again, the yearly waste, fraud and abuse in Medicare and Medicaid is 5 TIMES the amount of profit that insurance companies make.

Posted by: Ken at March 16, 2010 05:35 AM (4JpPD)

103

Our online shop sales GHD range of GHD Hair Straighteners products. If you are buying GHD Straighteners and Ghd flat iron online through the internet, then we will give you more discounts.In addition, free postage.cheap GHD Straighteners Shop for high quality wholesale GHD hair straighteners and ghd MK4 products on DHgate and get worldwide delivery. Buy Chinese cheap GHD hair straighteners wholesale producted from China wholesale supplies.

Posted by: shape ups shoes at March 16, 2010 05:37 PM (3iGDt)

104 i very much impressive to read this post, thanks
<a href="http://www.bali-villas-seminyak.com">Bali Seminyak Villas</a> 

Posted by: bali seminyak villas at May 07, 2010 04:38 PM (KS2tp)

Posted by: puma shoes at June 10, 2010 01:44 AM (FhbzM)

Posted by: OjfleHsEHa at June 23, 2010 04:31 PM (abm4r)

107 good new about that context. The current "system" cares a hell of a lot more about Natoma's well-being than Obama does.I need health insurance

Posted by: isocial at July 28, 2010 01:21 AM (QDxA3)

108 the most cost-effective gucci's handbags, wallets, travel & business series in www.gucci1923.com
welcome, we are sure that you will get a great experience in our shopping site.






Posted by: gucci1923 at August 14, 2010 09:13 AM (f6HI3)

Hide Comments | Add Comment | Refresh | Top

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
138kb generated in CPU 0.2919, elapsed 0.4472 seconds.
64 queries taking 0.3896 seconds, 236 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.