February 04, 2011

In Defense of Amy Chua
— Geoff

Those Chinese tiger moms must be doing something right:
UnemploymentbyRace.gif
From the latest Bureau of Labor Standards release (much more on unemployment to come in a bit).

Posted by: Geoff at 06:06 AM | Comments (125)
Post contains 36 words, total size 1 kb.

1 It's not that far off from whites either.

Posted by: EC at February 04, 2011 06:08 AM (mAhn3)

2 Why are we keeping racist statistics?

Posted by: tcn at February 04, 2011 06:08 AM (DjPot)

3 To be fair, a good portion of those are employed in my harem/

Posted by: In Exile at February 04, 2011 06:10 AM (IlzLB)

4 When you expect more from children they give you more, and that becomes a lifelong habit. More power to the Tiger Moms.

Posted by: joncelli at February 04, 2011 06:10 AM (RD7QR)

5
I was prompted to make this chart because the BLS highlighted those stats in their press release. They may have done it before, but this is the first time I noticed it, and it seemed sort of odd.

Posted by: geoff at February 04, 2011 06:11 AM (s4b+9)

6 7. When you expect more from ANYONE they give you more! It's not meanness - it's RESPECT and BELIEVING in the abilities of everyone!

Posted by: BlackOrchid at February 04, 2011 06:12 AM (SB0V2)

7 The statistics for earnings are substantially similar.  Asians come in the lead, followed by whites, hispanics, and finally blacks.  Despite arriving in conditions equally terrible to other immigrants, asians have typically done quite well.  I guess coming from two-parent households helps.

Posted by: In Exile at February 04, 2011 06:12 AM (IlzLB)

8 I wonder what kind of kid Tiger's Dad and TigerMom would've produced?

Posted by: LIncolntf at February 04, 2011 06:13 AM (hUf/c)

9 Minorities highest unemployment rate. Obama reelection bid hardest hit.

Posted by: JackStraw at February 04, 2011 06:13 AM (TMB3S)

10 Are you sure those aren't "European Asians"?

The kind that like to blow stuff up in the UK.

Posted by: Buzzsaw at February 04, 2011 06:13 AM (tf9Ne)

11 They have a tendency to employ themselves as well.  One of the reasons they appreciate our country - they can start businesses.

Posted by: aeroplane at February 04, 2011 06:16 AM (fgc9M)

12 this is the first time I noticed it, and it seemed sort of odd.
Posted by: geoff at February 04, 2011 10:11 AM

New, race-based "entitlement"/giveaway programs -- to those "hardest hit," of course -- in 5...4...3...2....

Posted by: MrScribbler© at February 04, 2011 06:17 AM (Ulu3i)

13 If you eliminate racism from this, what could possibly explain this?

Posted by: Percopius at February 04, 2011 06:17 AM (rrs4u)

14

What percentage of them are emotionally crippled perverts crying in a corner wearing the scout uniform they never got to wear as a kid, while toturing a small animal and crying "Why mommy, why!!?"  Just curious.

Posted by: Joanie (Oven Gloves) at February 04, 2011 06:18 AM (HaYO4)

15 I await Geoff's new charts and analysis.  9.0% is "unexpected" good news, although I haven't seen the adjustments yet.  I figured the rate was going to go back up.

Posted by: Guy Fawkes at February 04, 2011 06:19 AM (xdHzq)

16 When you expect more from children they give you more, and that becomes a lifelong habit.

Posted by: joncelli at February 04, 2011 10:10 AM (RD7QR)

In less than two years after entering my stepsons' lives, the youngest went from crap grades and not liking simple math because he couldn't do it to almost straight A's and loving math.  The teenager has gone from lazy and apathetic, to motivated and developing a plan for his life. 

None of these things were demands, but expectations.  Their mom was just coddling them and trying to protect them and make their life easier.  Admirable, but I told her she wasn't doing them any favors. 

(I also think having a strong, responsible male role-model for the first time in their life might have had a wee bit to do with that as well.)

So, as to your comment - yeah!

Posted by: Burn the Witch at February 04, 2011 06:19 AM (A/oSU)

17 Interesting. My mother refused to let me choose my own friends or my clothes or my extra-curricular activities, much like Amy Chua describes, and that's not helping me find a job. 

Anyway, I'm sure the chart is raaaaaaacist, as is the implication that the government schools aren't raising black children right.

Posted by: HeatherRadish at February 04, 2011 06:19 AM (TUpD9)

18 If you eliminate racism from this, what could possibly explain this?

I would guess it correlates to how much each group is taught they are entitled to other peoples money.

Posted by: Buzzsaw at February 04, 2011 06:20 AM (tf9Ne)

19 If only the numbers weren't BS to begin with...

Posted by: ParisParamus at February 04, 2011 06:21 AM (3/GGc)

20 This chart kind of takes me back to when the U of Michigan law school was doing their "affirmative action" plan with minority student (black, hispanic, native American Indian) admissions.  Being a minority applicant automatically gave you bonus points on your application to give you an edge over other applicants.  What was later found out was that asians (oriental and Indian) applicants did NOT receive this bonus, even though they are quite clearly "minorities".  They weren't given extra points because they routinely placed similarily to white applicants in terms of test scores and abilities.

Some minorities are clearly more equal than others.

Fuck AA.

Posted by: EC at February 04, 2011 06:23 AM (mAhn3)

21 This has been said over and over again by everyone from Thomas Sowel to Bill Cosby and every conservative in the US. The quickest route to poverty and unemployment is to quit school get pregnant out of wedlock and go on the dole. If you look at the statistics for out of wedlock/school dropouts you will see the absolute correlation with those charts.  It really isn't tiger moms so much as it is stable families.

Now I have said this a million times but it bears repeating until someone hears it.  These statistics did not use to be this way. LBJ's great society destroyed black families and is making great inroads on the other races now.

Until the programs of the great society are eliminated these numbers will keep getting worse.

Posted by: Vic at February 04, 2011 06:23 AM (M9Ie6)

22 It would be nice if we could add one more person to that chart in 2012.

Posted by: George Orwell at February 04, 2011 06:27 AM (AZGON)

23 obviously, we need more Blasians.

Posted by: negentropy at February 04, 2011 06:28 AM (27KAF)

24 when 1.1 Million people are now taken OUT

Yeah, haven't had time to look closely, but a .4% manipulation would seem big even for these slimeballs.

Posted by: Guy Fawkes at February 04, 2011 06:29 AM (xdHzq)

25 I suspect that the discrepancy between asian unemployment rates and the others is due to the fact that so many porn stars are asian women.

Posted by: Truman North at February 04, 2011 06:30 AM (8ay4x)

26

From ZH:

Probably the last chart to bury any doubt about just how truly horrible today's employment data was, comes from a little observed data metric: that showing the number of people who are not in the labor force, but who want a job now. The number just hit 6,643K, a jump of 431K from December, and the highest number in history. These are people that would send the unemployment rate to about 12% if they were in the labor force. Nothing else needs to be said.

Posted by: Velvet Ambition at February 04, 2011 06:30 AM (w/3ed)

27

Hard for the numbers to go back up when 1.1 Million people are now taken OUT of the equation i.e. those no longer looking for work.

Posted by: CDR M at February 04, 2011 10:24 AM

My theory is that the BLS is operating under the same "rules" as the CBO: they take numbers they're given, and adjust to suit the Mohammedan Mouthpiece's (ours, that is) and Democrats'orders.

Posted by: MrScribbler© at February 04, 2011 06:30 AM (Ulu3i)

28 I'm also not sure how "black and Hispanic parents should chain their kindergarteners to a piano and force them to play Mozart until they cry" is going to spur job creation.  But that's why I'm a moron.

Posted by: HeatherRadish at February 04, 2011 06:30 AM (TUpD9)

29 Does this include NHL stats? Oh, SNAP!

Posted by: Empire of Jeff at February 04, 2011 06:31 AM (aFBR5)

30 How does this help my children?

Posted by: The one with the big ass at February 04, 2011 06:34 AM (vSiVD)

31 Green jobs, that will save this country, yep.

Posted by: The Robot Devil at February 04, 2011 06:34 AM (LdYLm)

32 Forget the unemployment stats... crime rates and school grades also show that given the choice between an anal Tiger Mom and 'it takes a village to raise 3 or 4 bastards' that Tiger Mom wins out hands down. And something studiously avoided by the MFM in all the commentary about Mrs Chua's column.

Posted by: andycanuck at February 04, 2011 06:34 AM (2rOwc)

33 It seems pretty clear from this chart that Whites and Asians are doing the jobs that Hispanics and Blacks just won't do. Oh, hang on a second... SELF-DENUNCIATION MODE: ACTIVE

Posted by: Empire of Jeff at February 04, 2011 06:34 AM (aFBR5)

34 10 I wonder what kind of kid Tiger's Dad and TigerMom would've produced?

Tiger mom is married to a Joo professor at Yale.

Posted by: Kemp at February 04, 2011 06:36 AM (vSiVD)

35 I noticed there are no Filipinos on your little chart.  Because,  what the hell are they anyway?

Posted by: Dang at February 04, 2011 06:36 AM (TXKVh)

36 We beat you long time!

Posted by: Asians at February 04, 2011 06:37 AM (n0WLs)

37 42 10 I wonder what kind of kid Tiger's Dad and TigerMom would've produced? Tiger mom is married to a Joo professor at Yale. Posted by: Kemp at February 04, 2011 10:36 AM (vSiVD) No surprise. Jews and Asians have a similar respect for learning and self-discipline.

Posted by: joncelli at February 04, 2011 06:37 AM (RD7QR)

38 And what about the Jamaicans, man.

Posted by: The Robot Devil at February 04, 2011 06:37 AM (LdYLm)

39 In other news- it's official the Internet is full

Posted by: Nighthawk at February 04, 2011 06:39 AM (RSqz2)

40 46 And what about the Jamaicans, man mon. Posted by: The Robot Devil at February 04, 2011 10:37 AM (LdYLm) FIFY.

Posted by: joncelli at February 04, 2011 06:40 AM (RD7QR)

41 Maybe I'm just a racist fool, but it seems to me the "Tiger Mom" method basically raises an intelligent high-functioning ... drone. Oh, they'll make good money, but they won't - and have not so far - invented the next generation of anything.

Call me when the "Tiger Mom" kids start to invent things the way Bill Gates or Steve Jobs did. Too much regimentation is not good for one's creativity.

Amy Chua takes a good idea - demanding more from your kids - and takes it to a stupid extreme. And, because it is stupid and possibly harmful in the long run and sounds exotic and cutting edge, our media jump on it and push it as the next great idea in raising children.

Is this meme's 15 minutes over yet?

Posted by: Josef K. is really tired of all the Bushes at February 04, 2011 06:40 AM (7+pP9)

42

What percentage of them are emotionally crippled perverts crying in a corner wearing the scout uniform they never got to wear as a kid, while toturing a small animal and crying "Why mommy, why!!?"  Just curious.

Exactly. As much as I admired the Asian American folks I ran with in school, the rates of suicide are up there.

Posted by: Curmudgeon at February 04, 2011 06:41 AM (ujg0T)

43 I'm also not sure how "black and Hispanic parents should chain their kindergarteners to a piano and force them to play Mozart until they cry" is going to spur job creation.  But that's why I'm a moron.

Yeah, I'm fuzzy on the connection between killing a kid's bunny because he got a 92% on a geography test and them surviving a layoff years later.  Unless you've conditioned them to be such doormats management underpays them for the work they do.

Posted by: Bevel Lemelisk at February 04, 2011 06:41 AM (TpXEI)

44 17 I await Geoff's new charts and analysis.  9.0% is "unexpected" good news, although I haven't seen the adjustments yet.  I figured the rate was going to go back up.

Posted by: Guy Fawkes at February 04, 2011 10:19 AM (xdHzq)

Go to the chart, they have renormed the Population data... so with 36000 more jobs... and 100K more people a month from LEGAL immigration... it drops .4%.

If you can't fix the refults, move the data...

Can you say... East Anglia math department?

Posted by: Romeo13 at February 04, 2011 06:41 AM (AdK6a)

45 It looks like "having a job" is part of that "acting white" behavior that's avoided like the plague in so much of black culture.

Posted by: That Guy Hiding Under His Desk. at February 04, 2011 06:42 AM (TXKVh)

46 Oops ... sock off. I denounce myself for a lack of self-discipline.

Posted by: Josef K. at February 04, 2011 06:42 AM (7+pP9)

47 We beat you long time! I'm surprised at you. Asians are supposed to excel in learning. How could you forget the preposition "off?" And make sure your hands are warm.

Posted by: George Orwell at February 04, 2011 06:43 AM (AZGON)

48 I guess it's possible to take this too far. Kids need to play and there's no reason to be a sadist. But we're at the point now where kids are essentially left completely to their own devices. We need to strike a balance between license and expectations and we're too far on the license side now. That's all I'm saying.

Posted by: joncelli at February 04, 2011 06:44 AM (RD7QR)

49 It's all about the chocolate ration.

Posted by: eman at February 04, 2011 06:44 AM (n0WLs)

Posted by: maddogg at February 04, 2011 06:44 AM (OlN4e)

51 47 In other news- it's official the Internet is full

Posted by: Nighthawk at February 04, 2011 10:39 AM (RSqz2)

yea, it's been coming for a while. Of course, all the large SPs have been ignoring it. Kinda like the current fiscal problems.

Posted by: The Robot Devil at February 04, 2011 06:44 AM (LdYLm)

52 We need to strike a balance between license and expectations and we're too far on the license side now. That's all I'm saying.

Posted by: joncelli at February 04, 2011 10:44 AM (RD7QR)

THIS

Posted by: Josef K. at February 04, 2011 06:45 AM (7+pP9)

53 Well, this chart clearly shows the need for more spending.

Posted by: DNC Standard Response at February 04, 2011 06:47 AM (8RfPc)

54 Can you say... East Anglia math department? Who needs math? They just told us the current blizzards confirm global warming, and if we had a mild winter that too would confirm global warming. It's as if the academic world transformed into six year olds playing "heads I win, tails you lose."

Posted by: George Orwell at February 04, 2011 06:48 AM (AZGON)

55

Exactly. As much as I admired the Asian American folks I ran with in school, the rates of suicide are up there.

Posted by: Curmudgeon at February 04, 2011 10:41 AM (ujg0T)

Uhhh...still a lot lower than whites.  I definately agree that the "Tiger Mom" philosophy tends to raise drones rather than innovaters, but that is still better than unemployed loser kids (as in certain segments of society)

 

Posted by: In Exile at February 04, 2011 06:48 AM (IlzLB)

56 As much as I admired the Asian American folks I ran with in school, the rates of suicide are up there. Posted by: Curmudgeon at February 04, 2011 10:41 AM (ujg0T) Homicide too.

Posted by: Nighthawk at February 04, 2011 06:49 AM (RSqz2)

57

Curmudgeon:  a caveat, though.  China is the only country on earth where more women kill themselves than men.  Scary.

Posted by: In Exile at February 04, 2011 06:50 AM (IlzLB)

58 10 I wonder what kind of kid Tiger's Dad and TigerMom would've produced?

Posted by: LIncolntf at February 04, 2011 10:13 AM (hUf/c)

Tiger Balm.

Posted by: AmishDude at February 04, 2011 06:50 AM (T0NGe)

59

Who needs math? They just told us the current blizzards confirm global warming, and if we had a mild winter that too would confirm global warming. It's as if the academic world transformed into six year olds playing "heads I win, tails you lose."

Using the gore method of logic, shouldn't that be "heads I win, tails I win"?

Posted by: havedash at February 04, 2011 06:50 AM (sFD5n)

60 I enjoy a Happy Ending when listening to Asian concert pianists. You just don't get that from lazy whites.

Posted by: Empire of Jeff at February 04, 2011 06:51 AM (aFBR5)

61 So, Asian = Chinese now?

Posted by: JamesT at February 04, 2011 06:51 AM (blYjC)

62  we're too far on the license side now.

Really?  What I see is that kids aren't allowed to do much of anything nowadays without their parents hovering five feet away from them, trying to live vicariously through them.  I'm not sure if that's license.

In ten years I fully expect parents will spectate at their kids' proms.

Posted by: Bevel Lemelisk at February 04, 2011 06:51 AM (TpXEI)

63 Homicide too. Posted by: Nighthawk at February 04, 2011 10:49 AM (RSqz2) Nah. Cho was batshit. The fault there was deinstitutionalization and the stupidity of gun-free zones.

Posted by: joncelli at February 04, 2011 06:51 AM (RD7QR)

64

Exactly. As much as I admired the Asian American folks I ran with in school, the rates of suicide are up there.

What are the rates, btw?  I looked around when the "Tiger Mom" story was released and it seems that the suicide rates for AAs are still a bit lower than whites  IIRC.

Posted by: Kratos (Ghost of Sparta) at February 04, 2011 06:52 AM (9hSKh)

65 50 Maybe I'm just a racist fool, but it seems to me the "Tiger Mom" method basically raises an intelligent high-functioning ... drone. Oh, they'll make good money, but they won't - and have not so far - invented the next generation of anything.

Well, Amy Chua is a lawyer, what does that tell you?

Posted by: AmishDude at February 04, 2011 06:53 AM (T0NGe)

66

So, Asian = Chinese now?

Fair point.  The most successful group of asian immigrants in the US is actually Indians, and they have a substantial population as well.  JP/KR/CN tend to have similar educational habits, but they are certainly distinct from the countries of SE asia.

Posted by: In Exile at February 04, 2011 06:54 AM (IlzLB)

67 Well, Amy Chua is a lawyer, what does that tell you?

lol.  Tells me she doesn't know math or logic,

Posted by: Kratos (Ghost of Sparta) at February 04, 2011 06:54 AM (9hSKh)

68 So, Asian = Chinese now?

Posted by: JamesT at February 04, 2011 10:51 AM (blYjC)

Actually, "asian" isn't the correct word, either.  When you say "asian", you certainly aren't talking about Afghanis or Turks or Persians.  The illiterate language police took the correct word we used to use, "oriental", away and they haven't bothered to replace it with anything useful.  Typical libtard action.

Posted by: iknowtheleft at February 04, 2011 06:55 AM (N49h9)

69 What I see is that kids aren't allowed to do much of anything nowadays without their parents hovering five feet away from them, trying to live vicariously through them.

It seems like two extremes anymore. In one ZIP code, parents call teachers every day to discuss Special Snowflake's needs. In another, the only meal Seventh of Nine gets is his free school lunch, because the half the people who fucked him into being can't be arsed to walk down to the corner shop and use their food stamps for a box of crackers and jar of peanut butter and the other half is long gone.

Posted by: HeatherRadish at February 04, 2011 06:56 AM (TUpD9)

70 Really? What I see is that kids aren't allowed to do much of anything nowadays without their parents hovering five feet away from them, trying to live vicariously through them. I'm not sure if that's license. In ten years I fully expect parents will spectate at their kids' proms. Posted by: Bevel Lemelisk at February 04, 2011 10:51 AM (TpXEI) But not expecting anything of them, just overprotecting them. The key is: stand over them when necessary to get self-discipline and success; let them roam free when the time comes to let them be free. You know, like parents USED to do. 1. Come home and do your chores and homework, and let's see your test results. 2. Homework done? Chores done? Grades good? Good. Go out and roam free, and be home at 6:00 for dinner. Discipline + freedom = success.

Posted by: joncelli at February 04, 2011 06:56 AM (RD7QR)

71 Homicide too.

Better example.  

Posted by: HeatherRadish at February 04, 2011 07:00 AM (TUpD9)

72 Actually, "asian" isn't the correct word, either. When you say "asian", you certainly aren't talking about Afghanis or Turks or Persians. The illiterate language police took the correct word we used to use, "oriental", away and they haven't bothered to replace it with anything useful. Typical libtard action. Posted by: iknowtheleft at February 04, 2011 10:55 AM (N49h9) OOPS! ah, welcome to Asia Point...

Posted by: Nighthawk at February 04, 2011 07:03 AM (RSqz2)

73

I think you also have to look at the range of nationalities that are considered Asian.  We're not just talking about Chinese and Japanese, but also coutnries such as India, Pakistan, the Phillippines, Malaysia, and Indonesia.  How many of you have a convenience store in or near your town that's owned by an Indian family?  I'm in white bread NH, and I can think of at least two.  Businesses tend to pass from father to son.  Factor in the Korean laundries and Chinese restaurants, and you've got a substantial portion of small businesses in this country being owned and run very well by Asians.  I think it's less about parents tying their kids to the piano ala Amy Chua and more about close knit family units.

The problem I've encountered with Asians -- particularly recent immigrants -- is that they're very insular and standoffish.  First generation Americans with East Asian parents (Japan, China, Korea, etc) tend to overcome that particular hurdle, though, and merge quite well into Western society without abandoning their familial roots.  But we all know the horror stories of Middle Eastern families who don't like how "westernized" their children are becoming, so they marry them off to cousins back in Pakistan or send them to Jordan to live with "proper" relatives. 

Posted by: MWR at February 04, 2011 07:05 AM (4df7R)

74

Posted by: MWR at February 04, 2011 11:05 AM (4df7R)

Americans generally don't mean Indian or Pakistani when they say "Asian".  That's something that has come from Europe - Great Britain, more specifically.  If someone is talking about a Pakistani to an American and says, "Asian", there will be nothing but confusion.

Posted by: iknowtheleft at February 04, 2011 07:09 AM (N49h9)

75 Posted by: joncelli at February 04, 2011 10:56 AM (RD7QR) True enough- "Know when to say 'yes', know when to say 'no', know when to hold tight, and know when to let go". Easily said, but hard as hell to actually do...

Posted by: Nighthawk at February 04, 2011 07:10 AM (RSqz2)

76 25 It would be nice if we could add one more person to that chart in 2012.

Posted by: George Orwell at February 04, 2011 10:27 AM (AZGON)

 

Hear ya there...

We've got 4 guys around 50... all SENIOR IT guys with 30 years of experience, who have all made well North of 100K before... starting our own company back in California to compete with the Geek Squad on a local level.

None of us will be making squat... but at least we'll be working...

Posted by: Romeo13 at February 04, 2011 07:10 AM (AdK6a)

77

Profligate spending, skyrocketing unemployment, rolling black-outs in the southwest, circus-like foreign policy and a smug-condescending, leftist cabinet.

Yet, the man's approval ratings hover around 50%.

Gallup etal. is apparently only polling the smug, condescending, gainfully employed, Asian leftists of the northeast who have self sufficient homes and don't mind the creeping scourge of sharia law.

 

 

Posted by: dananjcon at February 04, 2011 07:11 AM (pr+up)

78

In ten years I fully expect parents will spectate at their kids' proms.


They already do.  At my youngest senior prom - there were lots of volunteer parent "chaperones" - or so she tells me.  I wasn't there.

 

Posted by: Dad of Two Daughters at February 04, 2011 07:12 AM (zh60d)

79 1. Come home and do your chores and homework, and let's see your test results. 2. Homework done? Chores done? Grades good? Good. Go out and roam free, and be home at 6:00 for dinner. Discipline + freedom = success.

Posted by: joncelli at February 04, 2011 10:56 AM (RD7QR)

Honestly?  I blame the 80's.  It seemed like every other story on the news was about a kidnapping in the 80's.  Between "Stranger Danger" and the missing kids on milk cartons, it was everywhere.  I lived in a rural town, but my parents didn't like me making the ten minute walk to the town's lake on my own, or with my older sister, for fear we'd get snatched by a passing maniac.  And my parents are not and have never been helicopter parents.  They grew up in the 40's and 50's when kids could roam around and get into all sorts of shenanigans, but still be home for dinner.  It was a scary new world for them, having young kids during the paranoia of the 80's.  And if MY parents were overprotective, I can only imagine what my lefty friends' parents were like.

Posted by: MWR at February 04, 2011 07:14 AM (4df7R)

80

Americans generally don't mean Indian or Pakistani when they say "Asian".  That's something that has come from Europe - Great Britain, more specifically.  If someone is talking about a Pakistani to an American and says, "Asian", there will be nothing but confusion.

Posted by: iknowtheleft at February 04, 2011 11:09 AM (N49h9)

Agreed, but when we're talking about federal statistics, "Asian" is inclusive of Pakistanis, Indians, etc.  So they have to be factored into any discussion.

Posted by: MWR at February 04, 2011 07:15 AM (4df7R)

81

Could for you Dad of Two!

 

 

That way you didn't see your daughters being dry humped by 3 boys at a time.

Posted by: kidney at February 04, 2011 07:15 AM (ENRGu)

82

Could = Good

yeesh

Posted by: kidney at February 04, 2011 07:17 AM (ENRGu)

83 Posted by: MWR at February 04, 2011 11:15 AM (4df7R)

It's hard to tell, since the federal statistics are such jokes.  Do you think that Saudis and the rest of the arabs, or the Persians, show up as Asians in these stats?  The page, itself, provided no actual definition that I could find. 

And my point was just what the average American thinks when he sees this category "Asian".

Posted by: iknowtheleft at February 04, 2011 07:24 AM (N49h9)

84 It was a scary new world for them, having young kids during the paranoia of the 80's.

I live within a mile of where Michael Devlin lived with his kidnapped boy-toy. I don't think I'm paranoid, but I do know that it *can* happen here.

Posted by: nickless the stil-banned (99.174.64.43) at February 04, 2011 07:25 AM (qdtoY)

85 This must have nothing to do with a much much larger share of asians being high skill immigrants or anything.  I'm actually surprised non-hispanic whites are so close to asians.

Posted by: jarod at February 04, 2011 07:26 AM (SN4+f)

86

I live within a mile of where Michael Devlin lived with his kidnapped boy-toy. I don't think I'm paranoid, but I do know that it *can* happen here.

Posted by: nickless the stil-banned (99.174.64.43) at February 04, 2011 11:25 AM (qdtoY)

The kids who did Columbine, used to deliver Pizza to my house... Guarentee some of my Tip money went to buy those guns...

Yet... my kids had more freedom than most... although less than my parents gave me.

Shit is going to happen... the problem now is that even though there is less shit happening, we hear about it much much more... its like there is less shit, but much more stink...

Posted by: Romeo13 at February 04, 2011 07:29 AM (AdK6a)

87

Call me when the "Tiger Mom" kids start to invent things the way Bill Gates or Steve Jobs did. Too much regimentation is not good for one's creativity.

Color me cynical, but this doesn't strike me as about raising kids. It's about selling books.

One thing I used to hear growing up was a colorful saying about throwing a handful of crap on the wall and some of it sticking.

Posted by: FireHorse at February 04, 2011 07:29 AM (sWynj)

Posted by: Vic at February 04, 2011 07:30 AM (M9Ie6)

89

I live within a mile of where Michael Devlin lived with his kidnapped boy-toy. I don't think I'm paranoid, but I do know that it *can* happen here.

Posted by: nickless the stil-banned (99.174.64.43) at February 04, 2011 11:25 AM (qdtoY)

Ok, now I'm convinced we had to be neighbors when I was growing up.  I lived about 1 block from the intersection of Big Bend and Sappington rd.  How close is that to you?

Posted by: Tami at February 04, 2011 07:32 AM (VuLos)

90

#83/#89 - Rather than categorizing people as whites, blacks and Asians (or orientals), perhaps you could eliminate some confusion by referring to people in the three categories of Caucasoids, Mongoloids and Negroids - old fashioned, but more appropriate. (Although their origins are Asian, there are tribes in the Middle East who are Caucasians.)

I'm skeptical that Mongoloids are out ahead of Caucasoids on the learning curve. Caucasoids are innovators. Mongoloids are copy cats.

Posted by: Brian at February 04, 2011 07:32 AM (sYrWB)

91

compare and contrast with the Asian moms

Posted by: Vic at February 04, 2011 11:30 AM (M9Ie6)

Which Asian moms?  The ones in China who, on giving birth to a baby girl, abandon her in the fields?

Posted by: Bevel Lemelisk at February 04, 2011 07:33 AM (TpXEI)

92 I believe the subject of the column is US Asian oms isn't it?

Posted by: Vic at February 04, 2011 07:35 AM (M9Ie6)

93 --perhaps you could eliminate some confusion by referring to people in the three categories of Caucasoids, Mongoloids and Negroids

You have something against Pygmies?

-- old fashioned, but more appropriate. (Although their origins are Asian, there are tribes in the Middle East who are Caucasians.)


Exactly.  But the inclusion of Hispanics for the feds shows that they are really more interested in ethnic classifications, for certain groups, than their racial classification.  Given this desire on the feds' part, one would think that they would have ethnic subcategories of mogoloid to correspond more accurately with Americans' views.  But, of course, obfuscation is a more the feds' intent than anything.

--I'm skeptical that Mongoloids are out ahead of Caucasoids on the learning curve. Caucasoids are innovators. Mongoloids are copy cats.

Posted by: Brian at February 04, 2011 11:32 AM (sYrWB)

In whole, perhaps, but orientals certainly score above whites in IQ.  It's oriental culture that has held them back.  China had many of the most important inventions long before anyone else, but no one ever benefitted from Chinese genius.  Even the Chinese didn't benefit very much from it.  They had moveable type long before the Europeans, but it was the Europeans who brought it to the world, not the Chinese.  And Chinese culture didn't allow the Chinese, themselves, to use that invention to anything near its full potential even in their own culture.

Posted by: iknowtheleft at February 04, 2011 07:41 AM (N49h9)

94 I believe the subject of the column is US Asian oms isn't it?

Posted by: Vic at February 04, 2011 11:35 AM (M9Ie6)

What exactly is a US Asian mom?  They're either American mothers or they aren't.

Posted by: Bevel Lemelisk at February 04, 2011 07:42 AM (TpXEI)

95

Posted by: iknowtheleft at February 04, 2011 11:41 AM (N49h9)

Yeah... Chinese invented Gunpowder, but it took the West to figure out how to really use it to kill people...

And Moveable type??? Indulgences baby....

Posted by: Romeo13 at February 04, 2011 07:45 AM (AdK6a)

96 Mathematical proof that character is destiny.


Posted by: Lee Reynolds at February 04, 2011 07:45 AM (/gY4D)

97

"All Chinks are Gooks, but not all Gooks are Chinks." --Robin Williams, quoting , supposedly, Richard Nixon.

The leftists can get away with not being PC as long as they think it's "funny." If a conservative said the same thing, he'd be branded a racist.

 

Posted by: GGinNC at February 04, 2011 07:46 AM (x7byD)

98 Not surprising unemployment numbers. If a group is know to "love you long time" why would you be surprised that they have the lowest unemployment numbers of all groups measured. As John Lennon said, "All You Need is Love".

Posted by: Tigtog at February 04, 2011 07:52 AM (Q5+Og)

99

How many of you have a convenience store in or near your town that's owned by an Indian family?   Businesses tend to pass from father to son.  Factor in the Korean laundries and Chinese restaurants, and you've got a substantial portion of small businesses in this country being owned and run very well by Asians.  I think it's less about parents tying their kids to the piano ala Amy Chua and more about close knit family units.

 

Nepotism.  It's what keeps Asian unemployment down.  How many Chinese/Indian restaurants or other service business have you been to that have anyone other than their specific racial unit working there.  White owned businesses will hire all kinds but the Asians rarely do.

Posted by: Speller at February 04, 2011 07:57 AM (J74Py)

100 92 It's hard to tell, since the federal statistics are such jokes.  Do you think that Saudis and the rest of the arabs, or the Persians, show up as Asians in these stats?  The page, itself, provided no actual definition that I could find. 

And my point was just what the average American thinks when he sees this category "Asian".

Posted by: iknowtheleft at February 04, 2011 11:24 AM (N49h9)

Part of my job involves reporting race and ethnicity statistics to the feds, and yes, those groups would be classified as "Asians."  It's a self-selected statistic, and the breakdown of how individuals make those selections can be made more specific with the inclusion of ethnicities and regional affiliations, but in the end those figures are collapsed into the racial categories as provided by the BLS.

And my point was just what the average American thinks when he sees this category "Asian".

With which I completely agree.  I do it myself all the time!  Of course, I watch a lot of Japanese TV and Korean drama...

Posted by: MWR at February 04, 2011 07:57 AM (4df7R)

101 105 Mathematical proof that character is destiny.


Posted by: Lee Reynolds at February 04, 2011 11:45 AM (/gY4D)

Then just how in the HELL do you explain our current President?

Posted by: Romeo13 at February 04, 2011 07:57 AM (AdK6a)

102 I agree with "iknowtheleft" We are vastly underestimating the creative abilities (in general) of what we're calling Asians. Vastly. I'm not too worried, change happens. Such is life. But they are absolutely smart, tough AND creative. Only their terrible politics has held them back, and I'm personally hopeful that this group will flourish (already is, really) here in the West. btw I see the same thing - it's obvious! - for Middle Eastern immigrants. I know several CEOs who are absolutely brilliant, bless the US every day. They know they could not have done with they have done here back in Pakistan/India/Saudi Arabia. India for example is changing - my neighbors go back "home" every year and tell me they are shocked and happy to see how India is developing. I'm happy about this! All will be well, all manner of thing will be well, as the good Saint said . . .

Posted by: BlackOrchid at February 04, 2011 07:59 AM (SB0V2)

103

You have something against Pygmies?

 

Only that little liberal shit, Richard Dreyfus. Otherwise, I'm ambivalent.



 

Posted by: Brian at February 04, 2011 07:59 AM (sYrWB)

104 Posted by: Romeo13 at February 04, 2011 11:45 AM (AdK6a)

Yep.  And the Mongols did more to use and spread Chinese genius than the Chinese ever did.

Posted by: iknowtheleft at February 04, 2011 08:00 AM (N49h9)

105

Nepotism.  It's what keeps Asian unemployment down.  How many Chinese/Indian restaurants or other service business have you been to that have anyone other than their specific racial unit working there.  White owned businesses will hire all kinds but the Asians rarely do.

Posted by: Speller at February 04, 2011 11:57 AM (J74Py)

Exactly what I meant when I said that the problems I've encountered with Asian immigrants is their insularity. 

Posted by: MWR at February 04, 2011 08:00 AM (4df7R)

106 Look at England vs. the USA . . . well before now but say in the 20th Century. We took our political system from them (mostly) and flourished. Success in other countries that take their inspiration from us (and England before us) - good news. Liberty and rule of law, not men - it may be lost here, but is taking seed elsewhere thanks to us.

Posted by: BlackOrchid at February 04, 2011 08:01 AM (SB0V2)

107 Ok, now I'm convinced we had to be neighbors when I was growing up. I lived about 1 block from the intersection of Big Bend and Sappington rd. How close is that to you? Posted by: Tami at February 04, 2011 11:32 AM (VuLos)

Those streets border our neighborhood. We're between them, Watson, and Lindbergh.

Posted by: nickless the stil-banned (99.174.64.43) at February 04, 2011 08:02 AM (qdtoY)

108
Maybe the differential are the ones who couldn't take it any more and jumped off a bridge?

Posted by: I R A Darth Aggie © at February 04, 2011 08:03 AM (1hM1d)

109

In whole, perhaps, but orientals certainly score above whites in IQ.

I disagree.  In studies where national IQs have been measured the orientals have scored higher than whites.  But the data was gathered by the governments of those same oriental nations and the people who compiled the studies didn't take into consideration the oriental cultural need to "save face" which would have made those oriental governments cook the scores to make their people look better.

Posted by: Speller at February 04, 2011 08:03 AM (J74Py)

110 Look at England vs. the USA . . . well before now but say in the 20th Century.

We took our political system from them (mostly) and flourished.

Success in other countries that take their inspiration from us (and England before us) - good news. Liberty and rule of law, not men - it may be lost here, but is taking seed elsewhere thanks to us.

Posted by: BlackOrchid at February 04, 2011 12:01 PM (SB0V2)

THIS.  It makes me think of Dinesh D'Souza.  His father DESPISED the British for their colonial control of India, but Dinesh looked at it and said, "They gave us law and industry and education."  With the internet and modern communication, colonialism doesn't even have to be part of the equation for the benefits of capitalism and republican democracy to spread like wildfire.

Posted by: MWR at February 04, 2011 08:05 AM (4df7R)

111

I think Asians, for the most part, don't have a psyche of victimization, but rather realize that if you work hard, you can achieve.  They don't feel inferior, nor should they.  They don't take out an inferiority complex on other races and society in general.

Any people, given the freedom and opporunity to learn and progress, will do it (eventually).  That's why islamic society is such an abomination on the human spirit.

Posted by: Dianne at February 04, 2011 08:17 AM (RPC8g)

112

Each year, the Census Bureau updates the estimates
to reflect new information and assumptions about the growth of the population
during the decade. The change in population reflected in the new estimates results
from adjustments for net international migration, updated vital statistics and
other information, and some methodological changes in the estimation process.

The population control adjustments introduced with household survey data for
January 2011 were applied to the population base determined by Census 2000.

From the BLS report...

So... they've had this data for ELVEN years, but NOW they use it to "adjust" the data for the Home survey?  Which, makes LESS people look like they are in the workplace?

Did they hire the East Anglia Mathemticians?

Posted by: Romeo13 at February 04, 2011 08:25 AM (AdK6a)

113

workplace?

Excuse me, should read WORKFORCE.

Posted by: Romeo13 at February 04, 2011 08:27 AM (AdK6a)

114

Those streets border our neighborhood. We're between them, Watson, and Lindbergh.

Posted by: nickless the stil-banned (99.174.64.43) at February 04, 2011 12:02 PM (qdtoY)

Yep, very close. 

Posted by: Tami at February 04, 2011 08:28 AM (VuLos)

115

In whole, perhaps, but orientals certainly score above whites in IQ.

 

Really?

Hmmmm, so you're saying that Socrates, Aristotle, Plato, Archimedes, Pathagorus, da Vinci,  Bell, Edison, Ford, Rockefeller and Einstein (to name a few) were orientals?  What of any noteworthy significance has an oriental invented or contributed to this world in the past three thousand years? Whoa, gun powder, big fuck'n deal. All of the most signifcant advances in mathematics, science, industry, warfare, all other kinds of technologies and higher qualities of life have been made by Caucasians.

Posted by: Brian at February 04, 2011 08:34 AM (sYrWB)

116 I took a course 20 yrs ago in which the leftist, black instructor informed us that the reason blacks were behind everyone else was because of their underlying philosophy. Asians saw their lot in life as karma, whites saw their lot in life as the result of their own ambition or lack thereof and blacks saw their situation as the result of someone else's (read "the man's")direct influence over their lives. His solution was for us (anyone non-black) to intrude even further into their lives by providing them with preferences and catering to their every need. He was too obtuse to see the irony.

Posted by: mark c at February 04, 2011 08:40 AM (SBIko)

117

The “Tiger Mom” thing is stupid and I’m tired of the meme as well. I think parents have the ability to raise highly capable, highly employable children without forcing them to play piano, returning their hand drawn birthday cards because they aren’t good enough, and calling them garbage continuously.

 

You know who this glorification of the Asian way of education and parenting serves? Progressives in the education movement because theyÂ’ll be using this kind of crap to argue for even more increased control over children in terms of lengthening school hours and shortening summer vacation as well as continuing to push through policies where 3 year olds are turned over to the public school system.  And you know what that results in? Good citizens who shut up and do what their government tells them. HeyÂ…that kinda sounds like China.

Posted by: ParanoidThursdayInSeattle at February 04, 2011 08:44 AM (RZ8pf)

118 Bill Gates and Steve Jobs aren't exactly upstanding models of creativity. Gates didn't really create anything new, there were GUIs before Windows. His was just moderately user friendly interface (that's so good it has to be updated every 3 years). Jobs just created an overpriced brand, not new products.

Posted by: Tom In Korea at February 04, 2011 08:47 AM (qkrg/)

119

I have not graduated from college. (My parents did not provide for it and frankly, I've been too busy working.) I've worked all sorts of "Joe" jobs--everything from fast food to warehouse worker to auto mechanic. My parents never made me feel bad about being a mechanic or a fast food burger flipper. What they did require was that I be the best damn mechanic or burger flipper around. Ability and opportunity are a crap shoot. Ambition and hard work are a choice.

In 2000, I moved to California with $200 in my pocket and not knowing a soul. I lived in a tent until I could get a job. Every place I went, I worked hard to understand the business, how I could increase the bottom line, tried to learn as much as I could, and developed my professional skills. 40 hours a week still makes me feel guilty.

Fast forward 10 years. I now live in NC (hard work is not valued in CA), have a nice house, a great wife, 3 kids, make over six figures, and manage an $18M portfolio of  IT projects.

I think the Chua method of parenting can tend towards being abusive, BUT, I love that kids are taught where their limits are and that obstacles must be overcome.

I am not that smart nor particularly gifted in any area. What I lack in intellect, I make up for in persistence. I HATE the idea that someone would take that away from me and tell me that the reason I wasn't successful was someone elses fault. What a tremendous assault on my dignity and value as a human being.

Unless you're seriously disabled, you can do something to contribute. If you're unwilling to help yourself, I'm not interested in helping you, especially if you reach into my pocket and take my hard-earned money to pay the bloated salary and benefits of a drone working at the U.S. Department of Redundancy Department.

Posted by: GGinNC at February 04, 2011 09:02 AM (x7byD)

120

"The “Tiger Mom” thing is stupid and I’m tired of the meme as well. I think parents have the ability to raise highly capable, highly employable children without forcing them to play piano, returning their hand drawn birthday cards because they aren’t good enough, and calling them garbage continuously. ..."

 

Posted by: ParanoidThursdayInSeattle at February 04, 2011 12:44 PM (RZ8pf)

 

Hear, hear!

 

mac :]

Posted by: macbrooks at February 04, 2011 09:07 AM (J+MD4)

121 My mom was not a "Tiger Mom", but my dad sure was!

Posted by: runningrn at February 04, 2011 09:12 AM (ihSHD)

122 It's been my observation that Asians do a very good job of taking care of their own. Look at any Asian-run business and tell me how many non-Asians you see working there. Unusually none. Seems like that might have an effect.

Posted by: Nemo from Erewhon at February 04, 2011 12:54 PM (/s4CV)

123 The Asian run business I am most familiar with is a grocery store run by a friendly Korean lady who works 6 days a week, at least 12 hours a day - probably more like 14.  They also own a few restaurants and employ a goodly number of people.  I believe most are Korean, but I am sure language enters into it.  I suspect some are relatives.  Her husband manages the restaurants, and I believe buys a lot of the grocery stock from wholesalers near NYC.  That means weekly trips of about 6 hours each way plus loading and unloading...

I don't begrudge her success, because I work hard but not that hard. 

Posted by: MarkD at February 04, 2011 01:34 PM (6CLxP)

124 The only thing I found obnoxious about Amy Chua's account is her inbred reference substantiating her sense of racial superiority. Also, so far as giving her admiration, I ask how many children Amy Chua is raising so "perfectly", only one or at most two?

Try seven. My mom was a tiger mom, so was her mom. We were literally and verbally whipped into shape. There was no doubt at any point in time what we were to be doing; mom made everything perfectly clear. No arguing tolerated. It achieved "results".

As a rule, tiger mom's effectiveness applies so long as they are stay at home mothers. When tiger mom becomes a "professional" leaving the kids in after school "Y" care, tiger mom's expectations remain in effect with their young elementary school children only for 18 months until they realize that their kids are no longer "under the thumb" and have lost respect for parents given so much time after school  developing peer relations whose constant bombardment sinks in to "quit working so hard, just don't care about excellence" eroding whatever habits the tiger mom established for home life. Children whose relationship with parents and family supersede  relations with peers will abide by tiger mom rules, of course. But not all tiger cubs continue to respect the "tradition as better" so far as the cubs are concerned, having converted to convenience and self indulgence along with their friends. Restricting your child's contacts with friends matters and determines the degree of "success". What you provide your child with at home matters, as well, since when you're not on their back, cubs will play.  With the musical instruction, you'll note as a rule that Chinese students study from Chinese teachers in America because the "Chinese" identity supersedes all with the Chinese tiger mom.

I've recently seen the same old fashioned methodology of parenting from German, French, Chinese, Korean and Indian Hindi parents as my parents practiced. So long as the mother is at home, home life is as the mother works to maintain.

Posted by: Plateau Plato at February 05, 2011 05:10 AM (H+LJc)

Posted by: cano at February 09, 2011 11:36 AM (wjTOH)

Hide Comments | Add Comment | Refresh | Top

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
146kb generated in CPU 0.1018, elapsed 0.2866 seconds.
64 queries taking 0.2341 seconds, 253 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.