September 08, 2013

Gun Thread (9-8-2013)
— andy

Epistemic Closure On Campus, But No Guns

This is a pretty funny piece from a newly-minted Indiana University professor in the HuffPo. The former President of the Brady Campaign to Ban Guns doesn't believe guns should be on college campuses. Who could've guessed that?

But wait, his argument is compelling and rich.

After I hired Colin Goddard to work for the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence, I heard him speak many times about the April 16, 2007 morning at Virginia Tech when 32 of his classmates and teachers were murdered, and four bullets were shot into his body. Two weeks ago I heard the story again - this time for the first time as a Professor at Indiana University with 66 first-year college students who are part of a new Civic Leaders program that I direct.

One of the questions after the presentation was whether Colin could have done anything to stop the carnage, particularly if he'd had a gun with him.

Colin's answer was clear. Everyone wishes that the story could have ended differently. Many people -- including Colin -- wish they could have been the hero we see in movies. But even though Colin had been in ROTC and was familiar with guns, he felt that if he had a gun that day, it would have been difficult to get to it in time, would have made him and others around him even more of a target, and could have led to other students being injured or killed. In Colin's analysis, the main lesson from that morning is that we need to strengthen our weak to non-existent background check system for gun purchases and make it a lot harder for people like his shooter (who had earlier been found to be a danger to himself or others by a Virginia court) to get dangerous weapons so easily.

I wonder how hard the Prof. looked for a different speaker who might present an opposing view? (actually, I don't wonder that at all)

It would've been easy to find someone to point out all the flaws in the thinking just in the excerpt above. How is it difficult to get to a gun in time if it's on your person? How does having a gun make you more of a target when you're already being targeted? What new law is needed to get the Seung Hui Cho's of the world entered into NICS (answer: none)?

But when you're trying to mint 66 new gun grabbers, you can't have their minds being filled with such conflict. Way to go, Indoctrination U.


News You Can Use

From the tip line, here's a link to AmmoRecall.com, a centralized source for gun and ammo recall notices. They have an email notification feature, but you can also just do what I did and follow them on Twitter.


Gun Of The Week

VestPocket.JPG

(answer below)

Marksmanship Award



Gun Of The Week - Answer

This one's from the tip line as well. I'll let Country Singer describe it:

Should you wish to use it, I came into possession of this revolver recently. My father bought in 1963-64 time frame while stationed in San Diego. I got it home and did a little research on it, and while it's not particularly valuable, it is interesting from a historical standpoint.

The Roscoe Arms Vest Pocket (also marketed under the Rohm and RG-14 names) .22 short (not LR) is pretty much the original "Saturday Night Special," which contributed greatly to the passage of the 1968 Gun Control Act. John Hinckley, Jr used an RG-14 during the Reagan assassination attempt.

Attached is a photo of the one I own, which is so poorly manufactured that there is no way I will risk putting a round through it.

The link is to an original advertisement for this model.


Must-See TV

Well done, Jon Alexander.


Cats & Dogs Living Together

The NRA submitted an amicus brief in support the ACLU's lawsuit over the NSA domestic spying scandal due to concerns that the data could be used to create an illegal gun registry.


Tips

If there are topics you're interested in seeing in the gun thread, please send them to AoSHQGunThread at gmail. You can also send them to me on Twitter at @AndyM1911.

The owner's manual for your concealed carry permit: The Law of Self Defense

Defend the Second Amendment. Join: The National Rifle Association * Gun Owners of America * The National Shooting Sports Foundation * Your state's second amendment org.

Celebrate America's firearms heritage: participate in Project Appleseed.

Posted by: andy at 06:25 AM | Comments (122)
Post contains 788 words, total size 6 kb.

1 This happened before last week’s gun thread but didn’t get mentioned then: “The Mississippi Supreme Court overturned Hinds County Circuit Court Judge Winston Kidd's injunction against House Bill 2 today. HB 2 defined what constituted concealed for the purposes of concealed carry. By defining concealed, the bill clarified that open carry is permitted under the Mississippi State Constitution.” http://t.co/NjPzWajdWO

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:26 AM (zpNwC)

2 The Legalities of the New Executive Order on firearms re-importation. “Basically, the Korean government still has a lot of M1 Carbines and M1 Garands sitting in warehouses that they’d like to sell to US collectors or to the Civilian Marksmanship Program. The Obama Administration has been unwilling to sign off of any of these re-importations to date. All this executive order does is make that official policy. In short, it doesn’t actually change much from the status quo. Without the requirement for State Department signoff, those M1s would be legal to import without any permission from the US government." http://t.co/t1kFjf3hIQ

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:27 AM (zpNwC)

3 Chicago Police Superintendent Says Cops Will Shoot Gun Carrying Citizens Because of His Training http://t.co/A5E4IXLJiv

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:28 AM (zpNwC)

4 As Sebastian said, “This article notes that there is serious difficulty implementing New Jersey’s law about the terror watch list. You see, it’s a secret list. As in, really secret. FFLs can’t run that check." http://t.co/ijiDpvjpbK

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:28 AM (zpNwC)

5 Rob Pincus, founder and head firearms instructor at ICE Training Company, on the topic of government setting standards for firearms instructors http://t.co/VeAyK2itUp

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:29 AM (zpNwC)

6 "Andy Traver was selected by Secretary of the Navy Ray Mabus on Friday to become the Director of NCIS. Traver is currently the SAC of the BATFE's Denver Field Division and was previously the SAC of the Chicago Field Division. We in the gun community know Mr. Traver as Obama's failed nominee to head BATFE as well as being an anti-gunner." http://t.co/PMzjtnm9eT

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:30 AM (zpNwC)

7 Fun video from Hornady Manufacturing on the ammo shortage. http://youtu.be/TseM5QkijJA

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:30 AM (zpNwC)

8 “After 38 straight months of increases in the NSSF-adjusted NICS checks when compared to the same month a year previously, the streak has ended. The NSSF-adjusted NICS checks for the month of August 2013 were 2.5% lower than August 2012." http://t.co/xLcvqtauo1

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:31 AM (zpNwC)

9 Buckeye Firearms Association Flips Mayors Against Illegal Guns Rally in Columbus, OH http://t.co/R7V0Dx1A4y

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:31 AM (zpNwC)

10 What if Obama gave a war and nobody came?

Posted by: Bluto at September 08, 2013 06:31 AM (C8V2U)

11 ATF staged an armed raid for the benefit of media coverage-again. http://t.co/U8JqBoGERU

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:31 AM (zpNwC)

12 Utah joins NRA fight to lift Federal ban on handgun sales to people under 21 http://desne.ws/4EWTZ8c

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:32 AM (zpNwC)

13 “The National Constitution Center, a false-flag organization that, under the banner of educating the public, is really part of the progressive project to destroy said document. They are proposing repealing the Second Amendment.” http://t.co/QeNQjCeLyw

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:32 AM (zpNwC)

14 the only thing .22 short is good for in a carry piece is a hitman weapon IMHO or a snake charmer.

Posted by: sven10077 at September 08, 2013 06:33 AM (9jfyN)

15 "Senators Chris Murphy (D-CT) and Richard Blumenthal (D-CT) are joining the call to get Starbucks to ban guns." http://t.co/fVEnnYbLCo

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:33 AM (zpNwC)

16 >>> Chicago Police Superintendent Says Cops Will Shoot Gun Carrying Citizens Because of His Training

Isn't this a kind of old story?  Or is he just repeating his statement?  Either way, deserves to be spread around.

Posted by: Bomber at September 08, 2013 06:35 AM (+Wfbd)

17 Bob Barr on ObamaÂ’s second term war on the Second Amendment. http://t.co/PRkuR1Q7ms

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:35 AM (zpNwC)

18 Got another message this week from Cabela's that my order of Federal Bulk .22 is still on backorder. I believe I made the original order in December 2012, but it may have been November. ¡Forward!

Posted by: jakeman at September 08, 2013 06:35 AM (GXKTh)

19 Picked up his and hers Ruger LCPs last weekend, and we test-fired them yesterday. Girlfriend put 5 of 6 rounds into the 12-inch square steel plate at 25 yards. Nice to know she's got my back.

Posted by: PabloD at September 08, 2013 06:36 AM (P2FJ1)

20 D.C. cops under orders to arrest tourists with empty bullet casings http://t.co/Bb5W6BiMm4

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:38 AM (zpNwC)

21 Gentlemen's Weapons Only Please http://t.co/4TG62GEx7d

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:40 AM (zpNwC)

22 Thanks Andy. I might have to send you a pic of my "goose gun" sometime.

And who would like a chance to win 32 guns?

If you would, here's the long url. (remove spaces)


https:/ /www.nra.org/sweepstakes/selection.aspx

Posted by: Joethefatman™ (@joethefatman1) at September 08, 2013 06:40 AM (MnSla)

23 And since we're talking about guns and college: Popular Pierce College pistol safety course now banned http://t.co/mlurZCp3g2

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:43 AM (zpNwC)

24 I swear I thought that was a capgun.

Posted by: steevy at September 08, 2013 06:44 AM (9XBK2)

25 The Sven J Olafson Budget AR-15 Build....

http://tinyurl.com/mhksdtn

R-Guns Lower 79.95

http://tinyurl.com/jw67493

CMMG Lower Parts Kit 69.95

Add ButtStock of choice

http://tinyurl.com/odte5ob
Special Ops Tactical 16" Midlength .223/5.56 Upper Receiver Group 499.95

Cost sans Butt Stock ~649.85

BUT.... on the "it is out there..."

Mate the complete Upper I just posted to a  Polymer complete lower at 120.00

http://tinyurl.com/or2b66c

619.95

So it *can* be done....

Posted by: sven10077 at September 08, 2013 06:45 AM (9jfyN)

26 The revolver shown is really a "Rosco" and aka RG10. The main problem with these and all RG revolvers was metallurgy.If you ever picked up any of the RG revolvers new in the box, you would note that they index and lock very tight. Now, to save a few cents, or a percentage on the wholesale price, Rohm elected to go with soft alloys to reduce machining costs. If one would look at a Model 14 RG with the 1.75" barrel, you would think you had a pretty decent little .22. However, the crappy material used caused them to "shoot loose" rather quickly.

Posted by: Bill at September 08, 2013 06:45 AM (uvyrw)

27 Shooting breaks out – at anti-violence vigil "Mothers of Murdered Offspring sponsored the vigil, calling attention to last Thursday’s death of Javon Booker, who police say was fatally shot when he allegedly tried to rob a convenience store on Tom Hunter Road in north Charlotte." http://t.co/F20i7R931c

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:48 AM (zpNwC)

28 *pads in on kitsune feet, tails playing cheerfully behind her. She pauses and looks at all of you.*

*She quickly and neatly writes upon a large dry erase board*

There is a gun show at the Trademart in Jackson, MS today.

*Shaking her head and with a flicks of golden ears, her emerald eyes twinkle. Then she pads off as quietly as she had appeared.*

Posted by: Anna Puma (+SmuD) at September 08, 2013 06:48 AM (PXI7n)

29 Wanted to show you all the new stickers on my car. http://tinyurl.com/pvbtuxq I'm sure it's my imagination that I get a lot of double-takes from other drivers. What? Women don't shoot? ps: I have a molon labe sticker to give away. Came in a sheet of four and three are spoken for. Lemme know.

Posted by: Gingy at September 08, 2013 06:49 AM (aH+zP)

30 "The former President of the Brady Campaign to Ban Guns doesn't believe guns should be on college campuses. Who could've guessed that?"

At Indiana University, a publicly funded institution, no less. Indoctrination U indeed, with tax money extracted from U, the taxpayer.

Mitch Daniels brought the smackdown on lefty nonsense at Purdue, where the professoriat were pushing Howard Zinn's commie crap. It appears more such effort is required elsewhere in the state.

Posted by: torquewrench at September 08, 2013 06:52 AM (gqT4g)

31 Posted by: Anna Puma (+SmuD) at September 08, 2013 10:48 AM (PXI7n)


Anna, depending on how my job situation goes in the next couple of weeks, I may be moving to Brandon.

Posted by: Country Singer at September 08, 2013 06:54 AM (LGM9b)

32 19 Picked up his and hers Ruger LCPs last weekend, and we test-fired them yesterday. Girlfriend put 5 of 6 rounds into the 12-inch square steel plate at 25 yards. Nice to know she's got my back. Posted by: PabloD at September 08, 2013 10:36 AM (P2FJ1) Very nice PabloD. I had issues when I rented a LCP at the range and ended up with a TCP instead. Same idea though. Super easy to conceal carry with a pocket holster. I plan to carry Hornady Critical Defense in it if I can ever find any on the shelves in .380

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 06:54 AM (zpNwC)

33 "Chicago Police Superintendent Says Cops Will Shoot Gun Carrying Citizens Because of His Training"

Actively boycotting Shitcargo now. Won't even catch connecting flights through their airports. Worth a few extra bucks to avoid the place. (Not that O'Hare is great anyway.) I commend the concept to the rest of you.

Posted by: torquewrench at September 08, 2013 06:55 AM (gqT4g)

34 Ginger, why must I sign up with twitter?

Posted by: Velvet Ambition at September 08, 2013 06:57 AM (R8hU8)

35 Good mornin Gingy

Posted by: Joethefatman™ (@joethefatman1) at September 08, 2013 06:58 AM (MnSla)

36 Lot of college campuses are already First Amendment free zones.  They may as well be Second Amendment free zones too.

Posted by: Linden at September 08, 2013 06:58 AM (YBusZ)

37 How do you spell douchebag? N-B-C, that's how. NBC published the recap for tonight's episode of Breaking Bad yesterday. They have since pulled it but google search still gives you enough to figure out what is going to happen. Still looks exciting.

Posted by: Jesse Pinkman at September 08, 2013 06:59 AM (NHMrq)

38 Gingy I posted a basic Carbine AR build that is easy...

if you go to multiple sources you can shave another 50 or so off....

Anyhow I promised Pac10077 and Lad10077 I'd take them Bow shooting earlier so I will...I'll be back around 1pm...

I am going to post the Build I plan on for a lightweight AR-15 Carbine Build for Lad10077 when I get back.


Hope the day finds you well

Posted by: sven10077 at September 08, 2013 07:01 AM (9jfyN)

39

Gun hatin'  university prof directs a Civic Leaders program?  So it's like the Boy Scouts, right?

Posted by: Count de Monet at September 08, 2013 07:02 AM (BAS5M)

40 Real expert Chris Hernandez demolished Colin Goddard's arguments against armed teachers in a response to another "expert" here: http://preview.tinyurl.com/pnn7byu

Posted by: Jim Vinoski at September 08, 2013 07:02 AM (Go8/M)

41

Colin's answer was clear...

 

That's a whole lotta wishcasting in that quote. I   bet   he     wants a pony for Christmas,  too.

 

Wonder where he keeps his   testicles?

Posted by: BackwardsBoy, who did not vote for this shit at September 08, 2013 07:03 AM (0HooB)

42 34 Ginger, why must I sign up with twitter? Posted by: Velvet Ambition at September 08, 2013 10:57 AM (R8hU --- You shouldn't, in order to see that. I don't lock my twitter account. That's dumb.

Posted by: Gingy at September 08, 2013 07:03 AM (aH+zP)

43 You forgot to ask ace if the gun of the week was a rifle.

Posted by: buzzion at September 08, 2013 07:04 AM (LI48c)

44 Wonder where he keeps his testicles?

Membership fee for the Brady Campaign To Ban Guns.

Posted by: Retread at September 08, 2013 07:07 AM (Oz+LZ)

45 I am sure there is at least one parent that may now wish the teachers at Spring High School outside of Houston were armed.  Might have stopped a stabbing, and prevented a death

Posted by: thunderb at September 08, 2013 07:09 AM (zOTsN)

46 Non-ironic tweet I saw a few days ago: @gradearadio That scumbag Zimmerman got his second speeding ticket. Where are all those racist tea baggers who said he was upstanding citizen? #bullshit Followed by: @gradearadio No upstanding citizen gets two speeding tickets in less than two months. Maybe Zimmerman can fake another rescue of a family. Asshole.

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 07:09 AM (zpNwC)

47 @BornLib: I got the LCP because my TCP, though accurate, had too many failures to go into battery, regardless of what ammo I used. Hasn't been an issue with the Ruger thus far.

Posted by: PabloD at September 08, 2013 07:10 AM (43vla)

48 To anyone who has a clue about tactical gun use, I had a question from watching the store clerk video:  Why was leaning over and holding out the hand effective against the guy raising his gun?   

From what I can see, he doesn't touch the guy, but it worked to prevent the gun hand from coming up.   Is that just because the wannabe robber was unprepared for reaction from his target?   So moment hesitation while trying to process "what is this guy doing?" and then, "oh-crap-gun-in-my-face".

But say if the robber was more prepared, and took a step back, then it would have been a quickdraw contest.

Posted by: ConservativeMonster at September 08, 2013 07:11 AM (Q80i9)

49 47 @BornLib: I got the LCP because my TCP, though accurate, had too many failures to go into battery, regardless of what ammo I used. Hasn't been an issue with the Ruger thus far. Posted by: PabloD at September 08, 2013 11:10 AM (43vla) That was actually the issue I had with the LCP. Life is funny that way.

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 07:12 AM (zpNwC)

50 29 Wanted to show you all the new stickers on my car. 
http://tinyurl.com/pvbtuxq

Posted by: Gingy at September 08, 2013 10:49 AM (aH+zP)


You put a fighting octopus on your car? 

(for some reason, that was the first image that showed up on first click.  Can't replicate it though)  

Posted by: ConservativeMonster at September 08, 2013 07:14 AM (Q80i9)

51 You finally realized you misfired when you have been using passwords like Mauser323 or Blue Rhinos40 as passwords on the net.... Red Flag Baby...

Posted by: Angel Eyes at September 08, 2013 07:19 AM (4L2D1)

52 BornLib

Thanks for the links

Posted by: Joethefatman™ (@joethefatman1) at September 08, 2013 07:19 AM (MnSla)

53 Posted by: ConservativeMonster at September 08, 2013 11:11 AM (Q80i9)

CM, there has been talk on this vid that it's 'staged'... notice the camera shake- since when do monitor cams shake like that, outside a San Fran earthquake?  Plus, it's focused in a bit too tight for any real surveillance purpose.

So I call b.s. on this vid...

Posted by: Mr Wolf at September 08, 2013 07:20 AM (UIAT6)

54 45 I am sure there is at least one parent that may now wish the teachers at Spring High School outside of Houston were armed. Might have stopped a stabbing, and prevented a death Posted by: thunderb at September 08, 2013 11:09 AM (zOTsN) A squabble between gangbangers. I can't get too outraged.

Posted by: Jesse Pinkman at September 08, 2013 07:22 AM (NHMrq)

55 Gold miners in remote Alaska town want answers after task force storms in "According to the article, some 10 agents - from 10 agencies - descended on this booming metropolis of 17 people - to look for violations of the Clean Water Act. TEN ARMED AGENTS in a town of 17 people. For the Clean Water Act." http://t.co/BShkKLZpJL

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 07:22 AM (zpNwC)

56

TorqueWrench.

Sorry, I didn't mean to get snippy in the last thread with my "spare me a few typos".  That was meant to come across as a sort of exhausted sarcasm (but then I realized it could be read wrong.)

 

Anyway, I live in the 'burbs (outside the "270 loop" as they say around here.)

The breakins seem to be opportunistic.  Although my neighbors have all taken to leaving their lights on lately. (Motion detectors are a waste because the deer set them off every night.)

 

And on that note horde, still taking a list of guns for a home defense weapon to be utilized for by a smallish Wife.  Something that's easy to store in a bedroom (so handgun form factor) easy to shoot, with limited recoil. Preferably easy to find used as well.

Posted by: tsrblke at September 08, 2013 07:23 AM (GaqMa)

57 Mr Wolf

That was discussed here the otherday and it was pointed out that they used a cellphone to record the video playback. I'm not saying it's real or not just pointing it out.

Posted by: Joethefatman™ (@joethefatman1) at September 08, 2013 07:23 AM (MnSla)

58 Murder,now speeding!This monster Zimmerman must be stopped! Libtard

Posted by: steevy at September 08, 2013 07:25 AM (9XBK2)

59   CM, there has been talk on this vid that it's 'staged'... notice the camera shake- since when do monitor cams shake like that, outside a San Fran earthquake? Plus, it's focused in a bit too tight for any real surveillance purpose.


At least for the camera shake, it's a video of a video being played.   

If you look at the "video controls" on the bottom part of the screen, those tell you that we're not looking at raw footage (no sane video recorder is going to put that junk into the video stream), and the shaking moves the video controls around.  

So that also tells us nothing about the zoom, as the playback may have zoomed in on the action.

Might be someone using a smart phone to record a color TV replaying the video.   (color surveillance video could be considered odd though)

Posted by: ConservativeMonster at September 08, 2013 07:28 AM (Q80i9)

60 Robber shot dead in home invasion "SANFORD — A would-be robber was fatally shot Wednesday and an accomplice was hospitalized after a homeowner returned gunfire during a home invasion on Marsh Market Road in northwestern Accomack County. It was the second time in the area this year in which the victim of a home-invasion robbery fired a shot at an armed intruder." http://t.co/lDomZaF1Xb

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 07:29 AM (zpNwC)

61 Gingy-  I have a stack of the Avenge Me stickers.  They go FAST; when people see them they absolutely want one.  I picked em up from one of those internet printing places, IIRC, Zazzle. 

Prolly one of the most popular ones I have.

Posted by: Mr Wolf at September 08, 2013 07:30 AM (UIAT6)

62 You're welcome Joethefatman™

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 07:32 AM (zpNwC)

63 Rons and Ronettes, I just recently snagged a JC (Jungle Carbine..Rifle No. 5 Mk 1) the Brits and malay's used to chase them Malay commies around back in the day (40's and 50's). I haven't seen them on the market for decades. I can't wait to get back stateside to see it!

Posted by: Judge_Roy_bean at September 08, 2013 07:35 AM (i42IE)

64 56 Anyway, I live in the 'burbs (outside the "270 loop" as they say around here.) The breakins seem to be opportunistic. Although my neighbors have all taken to leaving their lights on lately. (Motion detectors are a waste because the deer set them off every night.) And on that note horde, still taking a list of guns for a home defense weapon to be utilized for by a smallish Wife. Something that's easy to store in a bedroom (so handgun form factor) easy to shoot, with limited recoil. Preferably easy to find used as well. Posted by: tsrblke at September 08, 2013 11:23 AM (GaqMa) You looked at the Bersa Thunder .380?

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 07:35 AM (zpNwC)

65 61 Gingy- I have a stack of the Avenge Me stickers. They go FAST; when people see them they absolutely want one. I picked em up from one of those internet printing places, IIRC, Zazzle. Prolly one of the most popular ones I have. Posted by: Mr Wolf at September 08, 2013 11:30 AM (UIAT6) --- Dave has that on his car. It's spared us a few tickets, I'm sure.

Posted by: Gingy at September 08, 2013 07:43 AM (aH+zP)

66 @ 64, i would highly recommend the CZ 82, or the P-64. Available on the milsurp market for cheap. They shoot that 9 x 18 round (just short of a 9mm by 1 mm). They are kinda snappy on the hand, but my wife swears by them!

Posted by: Judge_Roy_bean at September 08, 2013 07:43 AM (i42IE)

67 This story might just PO a few people. I know it did me.

When Police Sue You



http://tinyurl.com/nb33wrl

Posted by: Joethefatman™ (@joethefatman1) at September 08, 2013 07:45 AM (MnSla)

68

25 The Sven J Olafson Budget AR-15 Build....

 

I'm going to have to check this out, been wanting to do a build. Nice thing is AIM is right around the corner. I just never thought about them for some dumb reason.

Posted by: PMRich at September 08, 2013 07:47 AM (KDUNf)

69 I read somewhere that the Jungle Carbine was going to be adopted as the standard weapon but that it loses it's zero.

Posted by: steevy at September 08, 2013 07:47 AM (9XBK2)

70 I'd be interested in that home defense list as well. Current gun is a .22LR H&K revolver. We have a cronic issue with thieves at our river place. I had to show the revolver last week, when backing up my boyfriend chasing off a couple of guys set up to camp in their van at the place. (They started arguing with him, saying they owned the place. Since I paid the property taxes this year, I know that's a lie. The local cops are worthless.)

I'm used to revolvers, but am willing to consider semi-auto. I'm going to put in for a concealed carry permit come payday.

Posted by: notsothoreau at September 08, 2013 07:48 AM (Lqy/e)

71 I prefer revolvers myself..38+P is perfectly adequate.

Posted by: steevy at September 08, 2013 07:50 AM (9XBK2)

72 >> the only thing .22 short is good for in a carry piece is a hitman weapon IMHO or a snake charmer.
 
Well, sven, Bill points out that the gun of the day is an RG 10; the gun used on Reagan was an RG14 which according to wiki fired .22LR rounds. I don't know about that stuff; just reporting what I'm reading on wiki. In any event, with Hinckley's 6 shots he scrambled Brady's brains, hit a cop in the neck, hit a SS agent in the abdomen (all 3 were on the ground), AND via ricochet on the last shot put a bullet within an inch of Reagan's heart. Reagan still came close to dying from blood loss.
 
If I recall correctly, .22LR is used to kill more people than any other caliber.
 
So faced with the choice of having a 22 or having to give your assailant some vigorous down twinkles, I'll take the 22.

Posted by: GnuBreed at September 08, 2013 07:52 AM (cHZB7)

73 64 and 66 I've heard lots of good things about the CZ 82 and CZ 83.

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 07:55 AM (zpNwC)

74 I took a closer look at the gun of the day vs the RG14 pic on wiki (under Reagan assassination attempt) and there are some differences. The length of the shell ejector is much shorter on the gun of the day.

Posted by: GnuBreed at September 08, 2013 07:58 AM (cHZB7)

75 Gingy, why do you have an ermine in your bathtub?

Posted by: lizardbrain at September 08, 2013 07:59 AM (EXDjY)

76 Gingy, you're a brick. Photo link goes to an octopus joke, beguiling one to go forward or back an arrow or two to find the correct shot of bumper stickers. And lo and behold, there are the prerequisite ONT shots. Galore. All hail the 'Ette.

Pics. It happened.

Alphecca has a link to the State of Iowa issuing a CCW to a blind man. Not just any blind man, but the president of the Society for The Blind. Read the whole thing, but a brilliant commenter notes:

ItÂ’s Class SH3 in paralympic shooting. Not part of their competition program yet, but thatÂ’s just blind prejudice, SWIDT.

Dark alleys hold no terrors for the unsighted. Notice, I didn’t go to “blind alleys.” Edward Arnold’s blind detective Duncan Maclain shot everything in sight — sorry — in that wartime movie series.

Yes, hard to verify that a place is safe to practice. TheyÂ’ll need a special version of the qualification test. Once you get past that, how much worse than a SWAT team could a blind man be? Think about this: would *you* volunteer to go in against him on his turf?
DidnÂ’t think so. Me neither.


Posted by: Stringer Davis at September 08, 2013 08:01 AM (JNUY4)

77 72 "So faced with the choice of having a 22 or having to give your assailant some vigorous down twinkles, I'll take the 22." 22 beats harsh language, no argument there. "If I recall correctly, .22LR is used to kill more people than any other caliber." I've read the same, but that's not the issue. Killing people isn't the goal, it's a byproduct. The goal is to stop the attack. Sure they might die from their 22 wound in a half hour, but that won't do me much good. I want something that either drops them right now or makes them decide they really want to be someplace else. 357 and 45 are the standouts for handguns in that regard.

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 08:02 AM (zpNwC)

78 @ 69, Yep I heard that too (loosing the zero). Some say its the lightening cuts in the receiver. Who knows? I just bought it because a JC only pales in sexiness when compared to a Luger! Now I have added yet another caliber, and 1 I have to reload for! Geez!

Posted by: Judge_Roy_bean at September 08, 2013 08:05 AM (i42IE)

79 I had the brilliant notion several years ago to pick up some .22 short for close-range practice, revolver only. To get it, I had to bu a brick, and it was not one penny cheaper than .22LR. If you're looking for why it's less popular, there it is.

Small weak cartridges retained currency for a full generation after they became obsolete. What made them obsolete was penicillin. One hundred years ago, a gut shot from a .22 or .32 was a death sentence. We look at things differently now.

Before the percussion primer, it was quite sporting to shoot sitting ducks. The advantage was to the ducks every time, with the long lock time and ignition trail of flint locks. Our notion of sporting shots in hunting changed in a generation.

No, I never recommend any .22 as a defense round. In the rare case of someone who has tried several pistols and just can't bear recoil, the .22 magnum is worth considering. Especially if you can load 30 of them.

Posted by: Stringer Davis at September 08, 2013 08:09 AM (JNUY4)

80 LOL, I have one of those RG-14's, although mine is branded as a Rohm and the hammer is a bit different. I bought it from a retired cop for $15. The one time I shot it the loading gate fell off and a spent cartridge was blown out of the cylinder right into my eye (I don't know why this happened, I suppose gas that escaped from the round I was firing went into the other chambers).

Posted by: ol_dirty_/b/tard at September 08, 2013 08:14 AM (5gerE)

81
   Have to comment here about the efficacy of .22LR for defense purposes.  I realize that stopping power is paramount but must say that if I were to put a half dozen rounds in someone's face, from my Woodsman,it definitely would ruin his day.

     That said,my carry is a 1911.  But if the .22 were all that was immediately handy, no qualms whatsoever using it.

Posted by: irongrampa at September 08, 2013 08:14 AM (SAMxH)

82 70 You won't hear me badmouthing revolvers. I have two from Taurus, and 82 and a 689. The 82 is a great CCW in 38 special. They also make a hammerless version, the 850, which is less likely to get snagged while drawing. Even though it is a snubnose the recoil isn't that bad if you get a model that is NOT one of the lightweight alloys (also avoid the polymer framed revolvers). There is also a 4" barrel version which should be even more manageable.

Posted by: BornLib at September 08, 2013 08:15 AM (zpNwC)

83 Posted by: Stringer Davis at September 08, 2013 12:09 PM (JNUY4) The nice thing about .22 short is how quiet they are. Fired from a rifle, they're quieter than a pellet gun. Great for pest control within city limits.

Posted by: ol_dirty_/b/tard at September 08, 2013 08:16 AM (5gerE)

84 One other thing about the RG-14: I can't believe the Germans actually built something that crappy. I would have expected something like that from a third-world country, but not from Germany. Not even East Germany after years of communism.

Posted by: ol_dirty_/b/tard at September 08, 2013 08:20 AM (5gerE)

85

The nice thing about .22 short is how quiet they are. Fired from a rifle, they're quieter than a pellet gun. Great for pest control within city limits.

 

So true, especially if you can find CB shorts. Obviously won't cycle a semi-auto - I use them out of a bolt action.  Rem Model 581. I got that one when I was 8, you know back when your parents were allowed to determine if you were responsible enough.

Posted by: PMRich at September 08, 2013 08:20 AM (KDUNf)

86 I'm used to revolvers, but am willing to consider semi-auto. I'm going to put in for a concealed carry permit come payday. Posted by: notsothoreau at September 08, 2013 11:48 AM (Lqy/e) Try both and see what you like better. Revolvers are simple, reliable, and easy to maintain, but if you have to engage multiple targets, a double stack semi auto has a lot more capacity. I have both a Springfield XD-9 subcompact and a S&W 686.

Posted by: ol_dirty_/b/tard at September 08, 2013 08:24 AM (5gerE)

87 34 Ginger, why must I sign up with twitter?       I was wondering the same thing, then realized it's because here at work we are still running an 'antique' version of  IE

Posted by: PMRich at September 08, 2013 08:24 AM (KDUNf)

88 I put half a dozen Aguila CB shorts into a trapped opposum's head to administer a coup-de-grace, and he was still making that possum face at me. I've taken to drowning them; it's more humane. Yes, I'll kill an animal. I feel terrible about killing one poorly.

At 50 feet a CB gives a marauding pack of canines reason enough not to return. Anything closer though, and you might be accused of trying to hurt the dogs.

I think they are fine for rats on the hoof. Other rodentiae, head shots only. And even at that, advantage rat.

Posted by: Stringer Davis at September 08, 2013 08:26 AM (JNUY4)

89 Posted by: PMRich at September 08, 2013 12:20 PM (KDUNf) IIRC, there's an aftermarket conversion kit with new springs and magazines available to convert a 10-22 to reliably fire shorts. I've got a Henry Arms lever-action that handles both shorts and LR reliably.

Posted by: ol_dirty_/b/tard at September 08, 2013 08:30 AM (5gerE)

90 > 72 >> In any event, with Hinckley's 6 shots he scrambled Brady's brains, hit a cop in the neck, hit a SS agent in the abdomen (all 3 were on the ground), AND via ricochet on the last shot put a bullet within an inch of Reagan's heart. Reagan still came close to dying from blood loss. ... So faced with the choice of having a 22 or having to give your assailant some vigorous down twinkles, I'll take the 22. Posted by: GnuBreed There's a difference between killing ability and stopping power. That 22 lr delivered a fatal* wound to Reagan. But it didn't stop him - he didn't even know he was shot. in a self-defense situation you want stopping power. The .22 lr is a joke in that regard. *saved by the ER. As to what works, there's nothing that's 100% certain. But large calibers work better than small. And high velocity hollow points work better than high velocity regular bullets.

Posted by: Comrade Arthur at September 08, 2013 08:32 AM (83xuc)

91
   For my money, the Marlin 39A is THE .22 to own.  Inherited my Dad's Golden 39A, after using it for years .  With a hammer spur and a 4x scope you cannot match it for squirrel hunting.

   Not to mention it's a tack driver and will eat anything you feed it.

Posted by: irongrampa at September 08, 2013 08:35 AM (SAMxH)

92 Gingy, I had a Molan Labe key chain custom made last year on Etsy. It's a small silver dog tag with the greek letters engraved, very classy and understated. I do make it a point to flash it in libtards faces though which probably isn't classy or understated Sven, The Bushmaster I was talking about last night is $50 more delivered than your build and I have a FFL that only charges $15 so that's a close call for only a $65 difference. Hmmmm.

Posted by: lindafell at September 08, 2013 08:35 AM (PGO8C)

93 tsrblke, I love my Kimber 1911 9mm and I am that smallish female. It's my CCH even though it's a tad large for it in my case since I am small. I'm comfortable with it and so far its what I like shooting the best handgun wise.

Posted by: lindafell at September 08, 2013 08:45 AM (PGO8C)

94 Forgot to ask for an update, Irongrampa. What caliber for walking stick?

I'll just presume your leg is gr-r-reat and you can barely remember the surgery, however walking sticks are habit-forming and useful in an alley; I'm wondering if you might decide to stay with it for sheer debonairness.

Posted by: Stringer Davis at September 08, 2013 08:47 AM (JNUY4)

95

I have an RG 24 in .22LR. Bought it in the early 90s at a pawn shop for $35. It appeared to be a well made pistol, but I didn't know about the metallurgy problems then. 2-1/2 inch barrel and fits my hand nicely. Shoots OK.

Unfortunately someone had dry fired it and nicked every cylinder. I had to file off the little nicks to be able to eject spent shells. It has a lot of gas leakage between the cylinder and the barrel, which makes me suspect the indexing.

Also pins in the frame work themselves out if you fire it repeatedly. I don't shoot it anymore.

Maybe I'll sell it to a buyback program and use the $ to buy a better .22 revolver like a Heritage Arms.

Posted by: Frankly at September 08, 2013 09:03 AM (BYyoM)

96 @  94

   Not caliber.  

   Gauge.

Posted by: irongrampa at September 08, 2013 09:03 AM (SAMxH)

97
   Mentioned on the ONT that today is the last car show for the year and I intended to limp around it for a bit.

  Time to go do just that.

    Have an excellent day, good people.

Posted by: irongrampa at September 08, 2013 09:12 AM (SAMxH)

98 Yesterday my wife and I went shooting. We shot her 9mm S&W handgun and also the .22 rifle (WINCHESTER MODEL 190). I had never handled the S&W, and had not shot the.22 in a decade(I thought it had been more recent, but upon talking to her I realized that it had been a whole whack of years since I'd shot grandad's rifle). Here's how I did: Using a standard target, with the 9mm pistol, at 15 yards, I put all 15 of the rounds inside the 9 ring. With the rifle, I put 16 shots in a 3 inch grouping at 25 yards using only iron sights(I was shooting at the "head" of the target.). So, my question: How did I do? I know that's not near enough to qualify me for any type of Marksman badge, but really, how did I do? Did I shoot well, or just throw lead down range? Either performance would be very disconcerting to a thief who broke into my home, and now that wife has decided that she likes shooting practice will make me better, but I have no objective comparison. Also, I'm having a real difficulty adjusting to my glasses, which I've been wearing for about 6 months. I've never shot wearing glasses. I need them to see far, but wearing them my makes vision blurry close, and that's where the sights are. Any farsighted morons have tips?

Posted by: Weirddave at September 08, 2013 09:17 AM (aH+zP)

99 Punch a small hole in a 1/2 inch disk of electrician's tape and stick it on the dominant side lens where you can comfortably see the sights and the target.  It will sharpen it up for you.

Posted by: Buck Ofama at September 08, 2013 09:22 AM (Eibjh)

100 "And on that note horde, still taking a list of guns for a home defense weapon to be utilized for by a smallish Wife. Something that's easy to store in a bedroom (so handgun form factor) easy to shoot, with limited recoil. Preferably easy to find used as well.

Posted by: tsrblke at September 08, 2013 11:23 AM (GaqMa)"



When it comes to handguns, find a range that rents them and let her try a bunch of different ones.  I took my tiny wife out and we started with .380s because she said she wanted something small.  She could hit the 8 ring at 5 yards but didn't really like them.  We tried some 9mm including the Glock because some people love the Glock at first sight.  She wasn't too impressed.  I figured I would shoot a 1911 because what the hell, we were there.  After I shot it she wanted to try.  She loved it.  I put up a new target and let her shoot at 3, 5 and 7 yards.  She could have passed the Texas CHL shooting test.  When we have some spare scratch, a .45 for Mrs.A-hole will be our next purchase.



That being said, for many years most police departments issued .38 special revolvers.  There is a good reason for that.  They are adequately powerful.  They are accurate enough.  And they can easily be operated by people who are "not into guns".  While not as cheap and common as they used to be, there are still plenty of police department trade ins available.  If they have several, ask to dry fire different ones to check out the trigger action, especially the double action pull.  Many police departments had armorers who polished the actions giving them remarkably smooth trigger pulls that you would have to pay big bucks to a custom shop to do if you bought a brand new revolver from the factory.  Have her start out with wad cutter ammunition.  This has very little recoil and it will help her learn sight picture and trigger pull before she learns to handle the recoil.  It is kind of like learning to drive a car with an automatic transmission before learning to work the gears with a stick shift.  Get the basic skills down before the more advanced skill.

Posted by: Obnoxious A-hole at September 08, 2013 09:24 AM (31Nrp)

101 I remember that gun well. It resulted in a law prohibiting the use of poor metals in firearms. 

Posted by: pat at September 08, 2013 09:44 AM (KCg4m)

102 When I went to IU (64 - 6 I kept a rifle in my room. I had a 'collectors' permit allowing me to hunt off season. I carried the rifle on the plane during trips home (stored in a closet at the front and returned to me as I disembarked). You guys just don't enjoy the freedoms I did at the time. And I didn't realize how the 60s would be the beginning of the end.

Posted by: Trainer's looking for a Militia at September 08, 2013 09:54 AM (tmzN0)

103 75 Gingy, why do you have an ermine in your bathtub? Posted by: lizardbrain at September 08, 2013 11:59 AM (EXDjY) --- I have no idea what you're talking about.

Posted by: Gingy at September 08, 2013 10:05 AM (aH+zP)

104 I have been researching self defense carry and am convinced .22LR is the way to go.

 
1.  Practice cost and recoil.  Practice as you fight.  Fight as you practice.  You're not going to practice  as much with a firearm that has relatively expensive ammunition that hurts to shoot.


2.  Stopping power.  A subjective concept that has more to do with fantasies of taking on a zombie banzai attack at the 7-11 than it has with any threat that is remotely likely to be encountered in the real world.


.22LR had stopping power enough for the victims of Hinckley and Sirhan.  One round in the back was sufficient to kill that Australian baseball player on the spot last month.  This Georgia housewife and the intruder she killed with a .22LR found it did the job of stopping an attempted burglary-rape just fine. Her comment to the 911 operator  -- "I shot him as much as I could." -- should be emblazoned on the door of the NRA HQ.

https://tinyurl.com/lz38m5r


3.  Zimmerman.  You want to defend but you don't want or need to kill.
Sure, the guy kept running -- for about ten feet when he collapsed dead in the lady's yard.

Posted by: Linden at September 08, 2013 10:16 AM (YBusZ)

105 I plan my next AR Build to be more like an homage to the XM-608 AirCrew Survival Carbine than a traditional M-4 style build.

NDS 601 Retro Lower 160 dollars

DPMS LoPro Slick Upper Reciever 87 dollars

and they're off...


Posted by: sven10077 at September 08, 2013 10:35 AM (9jfyN)

106 90.  "There's a difference between killing ability and stopping power.   That 22 lr delivered a fatal* wound to Reagan. But it didn't stop him - he didn't even know he was shot...."

It didn't stop Reagan?!  Reagan's next stop after Hinckley got done with him was the ER, a collapsed lung, a chest tube, then surgery and then a month in the hospital recovering from just a 22LR ricochet.  That's pretty darn "stopped".

McCarthy, Delahanty and Brady sure knew they'd been shot and they knew it instantly.  Hinckley's .22LR "stopped" McCarthy, Delahanty and Brady instantly and in the cases of the latter two, pretty much forever.  Neither ever worked a day after.  Same thing with Robert Kennedy, another guy that a .22LR "stopped" on the spot and forever after.  

Posted by: Linden at September 08, 2013 10:36 AM (YBusZ)

107

I would not use nor endorse an upper reciever without a dust cover ever

DPMS had two of my 308 AR upperfs in for warranty for over a year

Palmetto State Armory has better stuff IMHO

Posted by: DAve at September 08, 2013 10:51 AM (OksBo)

108 108 Do yourself a favor and get a PSA rifle kit and just add a lower (80% if you can swing it)

Posted by: DAve at September 08, 2013 10:54 AM (OksBo)

109 slickguns has MandP Sports complete for $599 now.  Hard to beat that econo-wise

Posted by: DAve at September 08, 2013 10:57 AM (OksBo)

110 If u need lenses to see far you are nearsighted. Lenses make back sight fuzzy. Had this problem since my days on the rifle team. Take a tip from archery - develop a repeatable anchor point. Cheek to stock or grip and rigid upper body for handgun. Your groups are already fine. The tip may make them a bit better but it will also make you quicker to get on-sight.

Posted by: Igotnothing at September 08, 2013 11:13 AM (4Gb8Z)

111 DAve,

the M and P is a great deal...

The original Designs for the AR were sans dust cover it was part of "militarizing"....

If I were making it for range work "yes" but it is a hobby gun.

Maybe I'll just get an M and P and rubber duck its furniture.

Posted by: Ted Kennedy's Eternally Burning Liver at September 08, 2013 11:17 AM (9jfyN)

112 http://tinyurl.com/qx6ca6s

Humorous Thread on the "Sportical Testosterone Inadequacy".....


I am planning on going with a nickle teflon BCG if that helps explain why I am ambivalent to a degree....

fun with metallurgy

Posted by: Ted Kennedy's Eternally Burning Liver at September 08, 2013 11:20 AM (9jfyN)

113 NEARsighted. Right. I knew I was some damn sighted. Thanks for the correction, I always get those two mixed up.

Posted by: Weirddave at September 08, 2013 11:28 AM (aH+zP)

114 Get a load of that fucking Rotsee asshole. "I shot M1 Garands at 5:30 in the morning a few times so I know all about urban combat" FUCK YOU. People like that do the most damage.

Posted by: Yoshi, Aggrieved Victim of the White Man at September 08, 2013 11:40 AM (YNK3y)

115 Posted by: Gingy at September 08, 2013 02:05 PM (aH+zP) Sorry. I went down for my nap too soon and didn't see your reply until now. When I went to view the photo at your twitter account, I saw among the rest a picture of what looks like an ermine swimming with a Barbie doll in a bathtub.

Posted by: lizardbrain at September 08, 2013 11:51 AM (EXDjY)

116 I remember that gun well. It resulted in a law prohibiting the use of poor metals in firearms. But, according to journalists, we have to ban 3-d printers!!!

Posted by: t-bird at September 08, 2013 12:49 PM (FcR7P)

117 Had a last-minute shooting session today at a gravel pit. Finally, a chance to put some rounds through my S'n'W MP15 Sport.

Drew a silver-dollar size black spot on a 4x8 about fifty yards away. Could barely see it. The front sight covered it completely (used the irons). Braced the rifle on a flimsy metal chair. Sent three rounds. Had a silver-dollar size group three inches low and two inches right. Whoa.

Of course, it doesn't have a dust cover, so it's useless. Oh, well.

Posted by: Taro Tsujimoto at September 08, 2013 02:42 PM (celt+)

118 > 106 90. "There's a difference between killing ability and stopping power. That 22 lr delivered a fatal* wound to Reagan. But it didn't stop him - he didn't even know he was shot...." It didn't stop Reagan?! When a man is coming at you from 20 feet away with a crowbar* you want to stop him NOW, not 30 seconds later. *typical burglar tool, typical home defense distance. Reagan didn't even know he had been hit for a few minutes. If you had been in a fight with Reagan he could have killed you before he noticed he was mortally wounded.

Posted by: Comrade Arthur at September 08, 2013 03:02 PM (83xuc)

119 Stopping power is interesting to debate.  A story I read many years ago described a pair of large football sized brothers that got into a scrap playing pool.   One brother takes out a .44 magnum and puts 6 rounds into his brothers chest.  The shot brother was so impressed he took the pool cue and beat his brother to death before he died of the gunshot wounds. 
     Stopping power.  Sometimes it is not enough no matter what you use, especially if the assailant is hopped up on something.  Shot placement may be of more value.
     People ask me where to shoot at the range.  I usually smile and tell them my preferred shots.  Throat and knee caps.  They usually don't believe me but ask why.  Well throat is easy you see you're aiming for the spinal cord.  That shuts everyone down instantly.  Not only that but it is below the helmet and above the vest so to speak.  But those targets are impossibly small and with a fast moving target . . . well not practical.  I agree!  Fast moving targets you put as many as you can into center of mass no questions asked.  However slower targets get those three.  Hard to move when knee caps are gone and hard to breathe when throat is smashed. 
     Practice is really the big deal.  Skill will come with time.  A .22LR through an eye will do fine.  Hunting is great practice.  Shooting a turkey in the head with a .22LR from 50 yards is a pretty good shot.  And that will be plenty of gun if you hit what your aiming at.  Shoot what you have confidence in and what you can hit with.  Want to have some fun start a nail into a board and see if you can hammer it home with a .22LR.  Then keep stepping back until you can do it from distance.  That's magic!

Posted by: Hammer at September 08, 2013 05:52 PM (96zHV)

120 Hey, that's my gun!  It was shooting to one side so I tried to bend the front sight a little to improve it and the blade promptly broke off.

I did note that a long rifle bullet would fit into it if I cut off a little bit of the nose.  I don't recommend this.  It kind of rattled a bit when shot.  I think maybe it could be loaded with six shorted 22 lr bullets for one use.  Six shots then break it and toss it.  Wear armor and have someone else shoot it.

Posted by: yooper at September 08, 2013 06:25 PM (0cBMc)

121 117 Geez taro you're better than this: of course the lack of a dust cover doesn't make an AR useless, it's just an econo-move that doesn't make sense for a practical shooter

Posted by: DAve at September 08, 2013 07:03 PM (OksBo)

122

Some friends and I went out and shot some sporting clays this morning. it was so much fun that I may never do regular trap shooting again.

Look into it if you haven't dusted off your shotgun in a while. Shot shells are readily available and $7.00-$7.50/box where I am so it's still a great way to spend a morning.

 

Posted by: Max Entropy at September 08, 2013 08:27 PM (Hc0n6)

Hide Comments | Add Comment | Refresh | Top

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
145kb generated in CPU 0.047, elapsed 0.2312 seconds.
64 queries taking 0.1971 seconds, 250 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.